Suppose $R$ is a domain, finitely generated over an algebraically closed field, and $\mathfrak{m}\subset R$ is a maximal ideal. Is $\underleftarrow{\lim} R/\mathfrak{m}^n$ necessarily a domain?


The two examples given by Qiaochu are singular points, one gives rise to a domain when passing to the completion but not the other. What makes the difference ?

Consider the normalization morphism of $\mathrm{Spec}(R)$. In both cases the normalization is the affine line parametrized by $t:=y/x$. For the first curve, there are two points in the affine line lying over the singular point $x=y=0$: they are given by $t=1$ and $t=-1$. In the second case, there is only one point $t=0$ lying over the singular point. This actually characterizes the integrality:

Let $A$ be a noetherian integral domain. Suppose $A$ is excellent (e.g. $A$ is a localization of a finitely generated algebra over either a field or $\mathbb Z$). Let $B$ be the integral closure of $A$. Let $m$ be a maximal ideal of $A$. Then the $m$-adic completion $\hat{A}$ is a domain if and only if there is only one maximal ideal of $B$ lying over $m$.

Proof. By the excellent hypothesis, $B$ is finite over $A$. Let $m_1, \dots, m_n$ be the maximal ideals of $B$ lying over $A$. A second fact resulting from the excellent hypothesis is that $B$ is excellent, and the normalization commutes with the completion. In particular, the ($m_i$-adic) completion of $B_{m_i}$ is integrally closed. It is an integral domain because it is integrally closed and connected (it is a local ring).

Let $K=\mathrm{Frac}(A)$. Then $B\subseteq K$. By the flatness of $A\to \hat{A}$, we have $$\hat{A}\subseteq \hat{A}\otimes_A B\subseteq \hat{A}\otimes_A K\subseteq \mathrm{Frac}(\hat{A})$$ where the last Frac denotes the total ring of fractions. We conclude that $\hat{A}$ is a domain if and only if $\hat{A}\otimes_A B$ is a domain.

Finally, as a general fact, there is a canonical isomorphism $$ \hat{A}\otimes_A B \simeq \hat{B}=\prod_{1\le i\le n} \widehat{(B_{m_i})}$$ where $\hat{B}$ denotes the $mB$-adic completion of $B$. Therefore, $\hat{A}\otimes_A B$ (hence $\hat{A}$) is a domain if and only if $n=1$.


This phenomenon of posing a question in the title and the posing its negation in the body is very curious to me. Anyway, it is possible for the completion of a domain to be a non-domain.

Let $R = k[x, y]/(y^2 - x^3 - x^2)$ where $k$ is a field of characteristic not equal to $2$ and let $\mathfrak{m} = (x, y)$. In the completion $\sqrt{1 + x}$ exists (e.g. by Hensel's lemma, or more explicitly by the binomial theorem) and consequently the defining polynomial admits a factorization

$$(y - x \sqrt{1 + x})(y + x \sqrt{1 + x})$$

so the completion has a zero divisor. This corresponds geometrically to the fact that $y^2 = x^3 + x^2$ has a singularity at the origin (the curve looks locally like an intersection of a pair of lines and this can be detected by completing with respect to $\mathfrak{m}$).

For a number-theoretic example let $R = \mathbb{Z}[x]/(x^2 + 3)$ and let $\mathfrak{m} = (2, x + 1)$. In the completion $\sqrt{1 - 4}$ exists in $\mathbb{Z}_2$ (again by either Hensel's lemma or the binomial theorem), so the same argument as above produces a zero divisor. Morally speaking this is for the same reason as above: $\text{Spec } R$ is singular at $\mathfrak{m}$.

  • $\begingroup$ Hmm, is this true for all singular points? (As in, is the completion of a finite dimension local ring an integral domain if and only if the local ring is regular?) $\endgroup$
    – only
    Aug 25 '12 at 1:00
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @only: I don't think so. Consider $k[x, y]/(y^2 - x^3)$ at $\mathfrak{m} = (x, y)$. It seems to me that the completion is still a domain (it just fails to be integrally closed). $\endgroup$ Aug 25 '12 at 1:03
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ The phenomenon occurs because people don't want to sound repetitive. $\endgroup$ Aug 25 '12 at 1:15

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.