Let $a,b,c$ be distinct nonzero real numbers. If the equations $E_1: ax^3+bx+c=0, E_2: bx^3+cx+a=0$ and $E_3: cx^3+ax+b=0$ have a common root, prove that at least one of these equations has three real roots(not necessarily distinct).

This question was a math olympiad problem.Below was my attempt but I've got confused:

I know that the discriminant of the equation $x^3+Ax+B=0$ is given by $-4A^3-27B^2$, so it suffices to prove that the discriminant of at one least of the equations is non-negative.

It's easy to prove that the common root $r$ must be real. Now assume on the contrary that all three equations had a pair of complex conjugate roots. Let $\alpha, \bar{\alpha}, \beta, \bar{\beta}, \gamma, \bar{\gamma}$ be the complex conjugate roots of $E_1, E_2$ and $E_3$ respectively.

Then by viete theorem, we have $$\alpha \bar{\alpha} r=|\alpha|^2r=\frac{-c}{a},$$ $$|\beta|^2r=\frac{-a}{b},$$ $$|\gamma|^2r=\frac{-b}{c}.$$ Multiplying the three equations gives $$|\alpha \beta \gamma|^2r^3=-1.$$ Hence $r<0.$ Hence $-c/a<0$ or $c/a>0.$ Similarly $a/b>0$ and $b/c>0.$ This implies that $a,b,c$ all all positive or or negative.

By symmetry, we can assume $a>b>c>0$, but then none of the discriminant could be non-negative. So what's wrong with the argument and how can I complete the proof? Thanks in advance!

  • $\begingroup$ "none of the discriminant could be non-negative" is contradict to your assumption "$\alpha, \bar{\alpha}, \beta, \bar{\beta}, \gamma, \bar{\gamma}$be the complex conjugate roots of $E_1, E_2$ and $E_3$ respectively". $\endgroup$ – Zack Ni Jul 19 '16 at 12:11
  • $\begingroup$ Your proof is almost done! $\endgroup$ – Zack Ni Jul 19 '16 at 12:11
  • $\begingroup$ I am sorry, but I dont get it, we have $a>b>c>0$, hence the discriminant of $E_1$ is $-4(b/3)^3-27(c/a)^2$ must be negative. Similarly for $E_2$ and $E_3$, pleas helps... thanks. $\endgroup$ – Schurik Jul 19 '16 at 16:20
  • $\begingroup$ All your reasoning is correct but the definition of the discriminant is a bit problematic: it should be $A^3/27+B^2/4$ $\endgroup$ – Zack Ni Jul 20 '16 at 8:08

Let $r$ be the common root, then

$$(a+b+c)(r^3+r+1)=0 \tag{$E_1+E_2+E_3$}$$

Case I:

If $r^3+r+1=0$, then $(ar^3+br+c)-a(r^3+r+1)=0$

$$\implies (a-b)r=(c-a)$$

By symmetry, $$r=\frac{c-a}{a-b}=\frac{a-b}{b-c}=\frac{b-c}{c-a}$$

$$c=\frac{a+b \pm i(a-b)\sqrt{3}}{2}$$

Or equivalently,

$$r=\frac{-1 \pm i\sqrt{3}}{2}$$

that contradicts with $r^3+r+1=0$.

Case II:

If $a+b+c=0$, then $r=1$.

For $x\neq 1$,






Since $a+b+c=0$, either two of $a$, $b$ and $c$ are of equal sign.

That is either one of $ab$, $bc$ and $ca$ is positive.

At least one of the $\Delta_{1}$, $\Delta_{2}$ and $\Delta_{3}$ is positive.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.