1
$\begingroup$

I have 6 boxes: $A,B,A',B',C \text{ and } D$. The box $A$ has $n_1$ red balls that are numbered from $1, \cdots, n_1$. The box $B$ has $n_2$ green balls that are numbered from $1, \cdots, n_2$. Make a copy version of these boxes $A,B$ are $A',B'$ (It means the box $A'$ has $n_1$ red balls from $1, \cdots, n_1$, and the box $B'$ has $n_2$ green balls from $1, \cdots, n_2$ ). These two boxes $C,D$ have no balls. Let $p$ be loss probability when we throw balls from a box to another box (each ball gets dropped with independent probability $p$). (For example, if we throw a ball from the box $A$ to box $C$ with loss prob. is $p=10\%$, then $90\%$ the ball will not drop. Then expected number of received ball in box $C$ will be $0.9n_1$ balls...).

First, I will throw these balls from $A$ and $B$ to the box $C$ with loss probability is $p$. Call number of red and green balls in box $C$ are $n_{1C},n_{2C}$, respectively. Then, randomly select $r$ balls from the box $C$, with $0 \le r \le \min(n_1,n_2,n_{1C}+n_{2C})$. Throw these $r$ balls to the box $D$ with loss probability $p$.

Second, throw these balls from these boxes $A',B'$ to the box $D$ with loss probability $p$.

How many (expected number) red balls do we have in the box $D$ in term of $p$, if two red balls have the same number (i.e number 4 of a red ball from $A' \to D$, and number 4 of a red ball from $C \to D$), then the red ball only counts 1 time? In the same manner, how many green balls do we have in the box $D$? Thank you in advance.

enter image description here

|cite|improve this question
$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ This question is very hard to read...there's a lot of unhelpful verbiage, the variable names are confusing and the picture doesn't add anything. I think, but am not at all sure, that you are asking this: "you have a bunch of balls, red ones $r_i$ and green ones $g_i$. Each specific ball, like $r_1$, say, has two independent ways of making it to box $D$. Either it goes there directly (probability $q=1-p$) or it goes there after making a stop (probability $q^2$) or it could reach by both routes (probability q^3). What's the expected number that makes it to box $D$? Do I have it right? $\endgroup$ – lulu Jun 30 '16 at 14:17
  • $\begingroup$ Note: if I have understood the question correctly (a big if) then it isn't difficult, and I'll write up a solution. If I have misunderstood, perhaps you could clarify? To stress: I am not at all sure I am reading it correctly. For example, I don't think the "red and green" have anything to do with it. There are just $n_1+n_2$ balls. Could be different colors, could be the same. $\endgroup$ – lulu Jun 30 '16 at 14:18
  • $\begingroup$ Thank lulu. My question is extended version of math.stackexchange.com/questions/1842299/… $\endgroup$ – user3051460 Jun 30 '16 at 15:13
  • $\begingroup$ Is my interpretation correct? If so then, barring blunder, my posted solution ought to be correct. If my interpretation is not correct, could you clarify the way in which I have misunderstood it? $\endgroup$ – lulu Jun 30 '16 at 15:16
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Oh, Ok. Yes, I missed that one. Not so easy to add that one in...let me think for a minute. $\endgroup$ – lulu Jun 30 '16 at 15:56
0
$\begingroup$

NOTE: as the OP points out in the comments, this solution incorrectly assumes that ALL balls in $C$ are subsequently tossed over towards $D$. That case may still be relevant so I will leave this up for now and will modify it if I can incorporate the filter from $C$.

Let $X_i$ denote the indicator variable for the $i^{th}$ red ball. Thus $X_i=1$ if $r_i$ eventually gets to box $D$ (either once or twice) and $X_i=0$ otherwise. Let $E[Red]$ be the expected number of red balls that eventually make it to $D$. Then by linearity of expectation $$E[Red]=E\left[\sum X_i\right]=\sum E[X_i]=\phi\times n_1$$ Where $\phi$ denotes the probability that a given red ball makes it (either once or twice). It's easy to compute $\phi$. The chosen ball makes it along the path $A'\to D$ with probability $q=1-p$ and it makes it there along the path $A\to C \to D$ with probability $q^2$. Adding these double counts those cases in which the ball makes it via both routes, which happens with probability $q^3$. Thus $$\phi=q+q^2-q^3\implies E[Red]=(q+q^2-q^3)\times n_1$$

The same argument shows that $E[Green]=(q+q^2-q^3)\times n_2$ and the final answer is just $$E=E[Red]+E[Green]=(q+q^2-q^3)\times (n_1+n_2)$$

|cite|improve this answer
$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.