I found the following problem, called Rechenschlange (literal translation: calculation snake) in a German puzzle calendar:

Fill the blanks with the numbers 1-9. Each number must only appear once. All operators are evaluated left to right.

 xx      xx  :  xx      14
  +       +      +       =
 10      11     12      13
  -       +      -       -
 xx      xx     xx      xx
  *  xx   :      *  xx   +

(Source: Harenberg Denksport 9. Mai 2014)

In other words:

$(((((((((((a + 10) - b) * c) / d) + 11) + e) / f) + 12) - g) * h) + i - 13 = 14$


$ \big(\frac{\frac{(a + 10 - b)c}{d} + 11 + e}{f} + 12 - g\big)h + i = 27$

How would I approach this problem mathematically?

My thoughts so far:

  • Just (manual) trial and error is not an option, since there are $9! = 362880$ permutations.
  • I tried to reduce the search space by going backwards from the result, but, so far, I only managed to deduce that $h \neq 9$. Which means I have only $8! * 8$ permutations left. Great! Then I got stuck.
  • The puzzle calendar's puzzles are usually not very hard (crosswords and number pyramids), so I doubt that the intended solution involves high-level number theory. There's a solution at the back of the puzzle sheet, but no explanation on how to get it.
  • Maybe there's more than one solution? Maybe there are so many solutions that trial and error is actually the right approach? For fun, I wrote a small script to solve this, which returned 377 unique $(a, ..., i)$ tuples. That's about 1 in 1000, so that can't be the intended solution either.

1 Answer 1


Unless there's some other unstated constraint, the problem doesn't have a unique solution. Even if you demand an integer at every step of the calculation, you get 301 distinct $(a,\ldots,i)$ tuples that qualify. My guess is that the constructor didn't realize (or care) that there is more than one solution. Writing a small script would be the quickest way to generate all solutions.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.