I have been stuck on this question for a long time:

Show that the $\Delta$-complex obtained from $\Delta^3$ by performing the edge identifications $[v_0,v_1]\sim [v_1,v_3]$ and $[v_0,v_2]\sim [v_2,v_3]$ deformation retracts onto a Klein bottle.

What I tried: I am aware that the way to do this type of question is by repeated cutting and gluing, until the diagram resembles the fundamental polygon of the Klein bottle. Unfortunately, I am not sure how to go about this.

I drew a basic picture of $\Delta^3$ as such. How do I go about making the first cut to identify $[v_0,v_1]\sim [v_1,v_3]$?

enter image description here

P.S.: I am aware of this question (Show that the $\Delta$-complex obtained from $\Delta^3$ by performing edge identifications deformation retracts onto a Klein bottle.), but I don't really understand his solution, besides in the comments someone said it is wrong.

Thanks for any help. I am looking for the simplest possible proof, if possible just using diagrams of "cutting and gluing", a proof-without-words of sorts. Not sure if such a proof is possible though.


Consider, in the 1-skeleton of the tetrahedron $T$, the closed edge path $$b = [v_0,v_1] * [v_1,v_3] * [v_3,v_2] * [v_2,v_0] $$ You can turn $T$ so that its projection onto the plane is a square, such that $b$ projects to the boundary of that square.

The square can in turn be embedded into $T$, forming a kind of distorted square $Q \subset T$, so that the boundary of $Q$ is $b$. One way to understand this embedding is that there is a homeomorphism between $T$ and the 3-ball taking $b$ to the equator, and under this homeomorphism $Q$ corresponds to the 2-disc bounded by the equator and cutting the 3-ball into two equal halves.

There is also a deformation retraction $f : T \to Q$. Under the homeomorphism described above this corresponds to a deformation retraction from the 3-ball to the 2-disc.

Now glue the edges, by an equivalence relation that I'll denote $\sim$, forming a quotient map that I'll denote $T \mapsto T/\!\sim$. Since the four edges that are glued form the four sides $b$ of the distorted square $Q$, we also obtain a quotient map $Q \mapsto Q / \!\sim$, and evidently $Q/\!\sim$ is homeomorphic to the Klein bottle.

Finally, the deformation retraction $f : T \to Q$ descends to a deformation retraction $$F=f/\!\sim \,\, : \,\, T/\!\sim \,\, \to \,\, Q/\!\sim $$


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.