Let $p_1,...p_n$ be points in $\mathbb{R}^n$. Let $P(x,y), Q(x,y)$ be functions with continuous derivatives in $ D=\mathbb{R}^2\setminus\{p_1,...p_n\}$ such that $Q_x-P_y=1$ for all $(x,y)\in D$. For all $i$ let $C_i$ be a circle of radius $r_i$ around $p_i$ such that $C_i$ doesn't contain $p_j$ for all $j\neq i$. Let $C$ be a circle of radius $R$ around $(0,0)$, such that $\forall i=1,...n, p_i \in C$. Let $I=\int_C (Pdx+Qdy), I_i =\int_C(Pdx+Qdy)$. Express $I$ as a function of $I_1,...I_n, r_1,...r_n, R$.

I was able to prove this considering that $C_1,...C_n$ are all disjoint and $\cup_{i=1}^nC_i \subseteq C$, but wasn't able to prove this when they were not disjoint. Here's the proof for disjoint $C_1,...C_n$ and $\cup_{i=1}^nC_i \subseteq C$:

Let $A$ be $C\setminus \cup_{i=1}^nC_i$. $A$ is a Green region, since it's boundary is $C\cup \cup_{i=1}^nC_i$, and therefore:

$I+\sum_{i=1}^nI_i=\int_C(Pdx+Qdy)+\sum_{i=1}^n\int_{C_i}(Pdx+Qdy)=\int_{\partial A}(Pdx+Qdy)=\iint_A(Q_x-P_y)dxdy=\iint_A1dxdy=\mu (A)$

And therefore, $I=\mu(A)-\sum_{i=1}^nI_i$, but since $C_1,..C_n$ are all disjoint and if we write $B$ to be the interior of $C$ and $B_i$ to be the interior of $C_i$, then, we get that $\mu(A)-\mu(B)-\sum_{i=1}^n\mu(B_i)=\pi(R-\sum_{i=1}^nr_i^2)$, such that $I=\pi(R-\sum_{i=1}^nr_i^2)-\sum_{i=1}^nI_i$.

In the case that $C,C_1,...C_n$ are not disjoint I looked at the case of only two that intersect. Let's assume that $B_1\cap B_2=E\neq \emptyset$. Since $B_1$ only contains $p_1$ of the set $\{p_1,...p_n\}$ and $B_2$ only contains $p_2$ of $\{p_1,...p_n\}$, then $E$ doesn't contain any of the points $\{p_1,...p_n\}$ and therefore, $P,Q$ and their derivatives are continuous on $E$. Also, if $E$ contains more than one point, then it can be proven that $E$'s boundary is a Jordan curve, and therefore, Green's theorem applies on $E$. Therefore, I figured out that $\int_{C_1\cup C_2}(Pdx+Qdy)=\int_{C_1}(Pdx+Qdy)+\int_{C_2}(Pdx+Qdy)-\iint_E(Q_x-P_y)dxdy=I_1+I_2-\mu(E)$.

From here on, I couldn't find a direction that worked.


Write $Pdx+Qdy=:\omega$ for short. Denote by $B_{i,\epsilon}$ the disk of radius $\epsilon>0$ around the point $p_i$. Choose $\epsilon<\min_i r_i$ so small that the $B_{i,\epsilon}$ do not intersect the large circle $C$.

Green's theorem, applied to the annular regions bounded by $C_i$ and $\partial B_{i,\epsilon}$ gives $$\int_{C_i}\omega\ -\int_{\partial B_{i,\epsilon}}\!\!\omega\ =\ {\rm area}\bigl(B_{i, r_i}\setminus B_{i,\epsilon}\bigr)=\pi(r_i^2-\epsilon^2)\qquad(1\leq i\leq n)\ .\tag{1}$$ We now apply Green's theorem to the "Emmentaler cheese" region generated by removing the $n$ small disks $B_{i,\epsilon}$ from the large disk $B$ bounded by $C$: $$\int_C\omega\ -\sum_{i=1}^n \int_{\partial B_{i,\epsilon}}\!\!\omega\ =\pi(r^2-n\epsilon^2)\ .\tag{2}$$ Subtracting the sum of the equations $(1)$ from $(2)$ we obtain $$I -\sum_{i=1}^n I_i=\pi\left(r^2-\sum_{i=1}^n r_i^2\right)\ ,$$ since all other contributions cancel. It follows that $$I=\pi r^2+\sum_{i=1}^n (I_i-\pi r_i^2)\ ,$$ whether or not some of the $C_i$ intersect $C$.

Up to this point there was no limit $\epsilon\to0$ involved. But note that you can consider $$I_i-\pi r_i^2=\lim_{\epsilon\to0}\int_{\partial B_{i,\epsilon}}\omega$$ as a kind of residue of $\omega$ at the singularity $p_i$.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.