20
$\begingroup$

4 cards are drawn from a pack without replacement. What is the probability of getting all 4 from different suits?

Here's how I tried to solve:

For the first draw, we have 52 cards, and we have to pick one suit. So, probability for this is $\frac{13}{52}$.

For the second draw, only 51 cards are left. The second suit has to be selected, so there are 13 cards from that suit. The probability is $\frac{13}{51}$.

Similarly, the third and fourth draw have probabilities $\frac{13}{50}$ and $\frac{13}{49}$ respectively.

Since the draws are independent, the total probability becomes $$\frac{13}{52} \times \frac{13}{51} \times \frac{13}{50} \times \frac{13}{49}$$

But my book says the answer is $\frac{{13\choose 1} \times {13 \choose 1} \times {13\choose1} \times {13\choose1}}{52 \choose 4}$.

My answer differs by a factor of $4!$. What did I do wrong?

$\endgroup$
38
$\begingroup$

The following uses a slightly different idea that is close to yours.

It does not matter what the first card is. Whatever it is, the probability the next is of a different suit is $\frac{39}{51}$.

Given the first two cards were of different suits, the probability the next draw is of a new suit is $\frac{26}{50}$. And given the first three were of different suits, the probability the fourth is of a new suit is $\frac{13}{49}$.

Thus our probability is $\frac{39}{51}\cdot\frac{26}{50}\cdot \frac{13}{49}$. If you like symmetry, and who doesn't, you may want to put a $\frac{52}{52}$ in front of the expression.

Remarks: $1.$ You calculated the probability that we get the suits in a specific order, say $\heartsuit,\spadesuit,\diamondsuit,\clubsuit$. But there are $4!$ orders in which the suits could come. That accounts for your being off by a factor of $4!$.

$2.$ The book solution is based on a somewhat different idea. Just look at the final hand we end up with, not the order in which we got the cards. There are $\binom{52}{4}$ equally likely hands. Now we count the favourables. The number of hands with exactly one spade, one diamond, one heart, and one club is $13^4$. For the spade can be chosen in $13$ ways, and for each choice the heart can be chosen in $13$ ways, and so on.

$\endgroup$
14
$\begingroup$

You have to multiply your answer with $4!$, because there are $4!$ ways in which you can choose the order of the $4$ suits.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.