Could someone tell me if I got this right?

enter image description here

So I drew a tree diagram

enter image description here

Sorry if it is too messy, but i had to do this on PaintBrush.

(a) I just added all the branches $\mathbb{P}(S_4 = 17) = 0.6 \times 0.4+0.4\times0.4=0.4$

(b)This one is a bit tricky, so basically I have $\mathbb{P}(S_4=17 | S_5=18)$ and forget about the equal sign and the numbers for now. So $\mathbb{P}(S_4 | S_5)= \dfrac{\mathbb{P}(S_4 \cap S_5)}{\mathbb{P}(S_5)} = \dfrac{\mathbb{P}(S_5|S_4)\mathbb{P}(S_4)}{\mathbb{P}(S_5)} = \dfrac{(0.6 + 0.4)\times 0.4}{0.336} = 1.19$

Which makes no sense for (b) because it is over 1...

Thank you


You need to compute $\Pr((S_5=18)\cap (S_4=17))$ correctly, compute $\Pr(S_5=18)$, and divide.

For the numerator, multiply probabilities along all paths to $18$ that have $17$ the previous day, and add.

For the denominator, multiply probabilities along all paths that end up ay $18$, and add. After all, your conditional probability tells you that your sample space is being restricted to paths that end at $18$.

Renmark: It is not clear from the diagram what transition probabilities you used. But at least one entry is wrong. Look at the path that goes $17$, $16$, $17$, $18$. For the $17$ to $18$ part, you put what looks like $0.4$ for that transition. But the day before we went from $16$ to $17$, so the probability of $17$ to $18$ the next day is $0.6$.

  • $\begingroup$ to your edit, yes I got it swapped on the picture, but not on my paper. Why would I multiply ALL paths when the question tells me GIVEN that I am on $S_4$? Don't I just take the path right after? $\endgroup$ – Hawk Jul 24 '12 at 0:56
  • $\begingroup$ Oh right, I was looking at my old formula. I think we have angered the Math Stackexchange Gods by extending so many comments, but I have to continue. You took the probability of the intersection of two events and added two "independent" (branches) events when you said all I was doing was computing the two items that the conditional probability requires, namely $\endgroup$ – Hawk Jul 24 '12 at 1:44
  • $\begingroup$ So I left the two up there because it is pertinent to my question $\endgroup$ – Hawk Jul 24 '12 at 1:49
  • $\begingroup$ Are these events actually independent? $\endgroup$ – Hawk Jul 24 '12 at 1:53
  • $\begingroup$ The transition probabilities $0.6$ and $0.4$ are conditional probabilities. The events represented by two different paths are not independent, in fact they are disjoint (which is why we add the relevant probabilities). $\endgroup$ – André Nicolas Jul 24 '12 at 2:00

each day you two things can happen. either the price goes up or down. There are two ways that the probability $S_4=17$ when $S_2=17$ Either the price goes up the first day and down the second. or it goes down the first and up the second. Since it went up the first day, the probability of the stock going up the third day is .6 and the probability of going down the fourth is .4 . The probability for the second method is.4 the third day and .4 the fourth.

Therefore the probability that $S_4=17$ on the fourth day is $.6*.4 + .4*.4$ = .10*.4=40%$ What you did is correct.

The answer you where looking for is correct. However as Andrè Nicolas pointed out, Your drawing doesn't add up. However, the result is still right.

Now, for part b, If the stock price on day 5 was 18. What is the probability the price on day 4 was 17? You need to take into account only the paths that take to $S_5=18$. How many ways are there for this to happen. The following: (-1,1,1),(1,-1,1),(1,1,-1). Lets take a look at the probability of each one. the first one is:$.4*.4*.6$ the second one is:$.6*.4*.4$ and the thirs one is:$.6*.6*.4$ both the first and the second satisfy the condition. Therefore, the probability is $$\frac{2/5*2/5*3/5*2}{3/5*3/5*2/5+2/5*2/5*3/5*2}$$ Which is equal to $$\frac {24/125} {42/125}=24/42=4/7 =0.\overline{571428}$$


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.