It do Carmo, in exercise 9.4, it is claimed that parallel transport along a closed geodesic in an even-dimensional orientable manifold "leaves a vector orthogonal to the geodesic invariant."

So, let $\gamma:[0,a]\to M$ be this geodesic, with $\gamma(0)=\gamma(a)=p$, and let $V\in T_pM$ be orthogonal to $\gamma'(0)$. Let $P_t$ be the parallel transport along the geodesic. From Picard-Lindelöf, it is clear that $P_a\gamma'(0)=\gamma'(a)$. Let $V(t):=P_t V$. I believe the claim is that $V=P_aV$. It is clear that $\langle V(a),\gamma'(0)\rangle=0$, so $V(a)$ lies in the same $\gamma'(0)$-orthogonal subspace ($T_pM^\bot$) as $V$. Let $E_1,\dotsc,E_{n-1}$ be an orthonormal basis of this subspace. Extend these via parallel transport along the geodesic. Then $E_1(a),\dotsc,E_{n-1}(a):=P_aE_1,\dotsc,P_aE_{n-1}$ is also an orthonormal frame of $T_pM^\bot$. Since $P_t$ preserves orientation (I have already proved this), there is an $O\in\mathrm{SO}(n-1)$ such that $E_i(a)=\sum_{j=1}^{n-1}O_i{}^jE_j$.

At this point I get stuck. I see no reason for $O$ to be the identity or what $M$ being even-dimensional has to do with anything. How do I continue?


1 Answer 1


You've misinterpreted the statement - you to need to show it leaves one such vector invariant, not all such vectors. (You can reasonably easily produce a counterexample to the stronger statement by constructing a flat $R^3$ bundle over $S^1$ with a twist.)

Thus the problem boils down to showing that every $O \in SO(n-1)$ has a fixed point, which is true exactly when $n-1$ is odd. If you're not familiar with this fact, you can establish it by studying the eigenvalues of $O$, remembering that any complex ones must come in conjugate pairs and that their product (the determinant) is positive.


You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .