In Ramanujan's Notebooks, Vol IV, p.20, there is the rather curious relation for primes of form $4n-1$,

$$\sqrt{2\,\Big(1-\frac{1}{3^2}\Big) \Big(1-\frac{1}{7^2}\Big)\Big(1-\frac{1}{11^2}\Big)\Big(1-\frac{1}{19^2}\Big)} = \Big(1+\frac{1}{7}\Big)\Big(1+\frac{1}{11}\Big)\Big(1+\frac{1}{19}\Big)$$

Berndt asks: if this is an isolated result, or are there others? After some poking with Mathematica, it turns out that, together with $p= 2$, we can use the primes of form $4n+1$,

$$\sqrt{2\,\Big(1-\frac{1}{2^6}\Big) \Big(1-\frac{1}{5^2}\Big)\Big(1-\frac{1}{13^2}\Big)\Big(1-\frac{1}{17^2}\Big)} = \Big(1+\frac{1}{5}\Big)\Big(1+\frac{1}{13}\Big)\Big(1+\frac{1}{17}\Big)$$

(Now why did Ramanujan miss this $4n+1$ counterpart?) More generally, given,

$$\sqrt{m\,\Big(1-\frac{1}{n^2}\Big) \Big(1-\frac{1}{a^2}\Big)\Big(1-\frac{1}{b^2}\Big)\Big(1-\frac{1}{c^2}\Big)} = \Big(1+\frac{1}{a}\Big)\Big(1+\frac{1}{b}\Big)\Big(1+\frac{1}{c}\Big)$$

Q: Let $p =a+b+c,\;q = a b + a c + b c,\;r =abc$. For the special case $m = 2$, are there infinitely many integers $1<a<b<c$ such that, $$n =\sqrt{\frac{2(p-q+r-1)}{p-3q+r-3}}$$ and $n$ is an integer? (For general $m$, see T. Andrew's comment below.)

Note: A search with Mathematica reveals numerous solutions, even for prime $a,b,c$. It is highly suggestive there may be in fact parametric solutions.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @Cameron's point is that those definitions are confusingly written. It would be much more readable with an equals sign for each of $p$, $q$, and $r$. They're not that expensive. $\endgroup$ Mar 28, 2016 at 19:39
  • 7
    $\begingroup$ General $m$: $$n=\sqrt{\frac{m(r-q+p-1)}{(m-1)r-(m+1)q+(m-1)p-(m+1)}}$$ $\endgroup$ Mar 28, 2016 at 20:25
  • 4
    $\begingroup$ This question reminds me of a proof I conjectured for Fermat's last theorem out of basic trigonometry. If you can find a parametric solution I think you'll be close to it. I think it's possible to show that every set of two or more prime numbers has a unique relationship with only one equation of the form $a^n+b^n=c^n$ and that this is always a pythagorean triangle which therefore precludes them satisfying any other $n\neq2$. The terms in your equation represent the dimensions of multiple triangles combined. It was just a conjecture that looked quite viable at the time, that this reminds me of $\endgroup$ May 19, 2016 at 18:01
  • 4
    $\begingroup$ @RobertFrost: 1. A very interesting conjecture! Even without solving FLT completely, it might form the basis of a nice elementary solution to Abel's Conjecture [about FLT], which currently has no such proof. 2. Perhaps there is a deep connection here with Bini's recurrence (also applied to FLT, c.f. Ribenboim's Fermat's Last Theorem for Amateurs), which deals with numbers of the form given here for $p,q,r$. $\endgroup$ Aug 23, 2016 at 12:46
  • 5
    $\begingroup$ @RobertFrost: No… Abel stated in 1823 that if $x, y, z$ are nonzero relatively prime integers such that $0<x<y<z$ and $x^n+y^n =z^n\ (n>2)$, then none of $x, y, z$ are prime-powers. It's been partly proven using analytical techniques, but not completely proven even with “heavy machinery” [excluding Prof. Wiles' result, of course!]. $\endgroup$ Aug 23, 2016 at 19:35

2 Answers 2


It can be transformed to next equation.

$$\displaystyle m=\frac{n^2}{n^2-1}\frac{a+1}{a-1}\frac{b+1}{b-1}\frac{c+1}{c-1}$$

so, function m decrease monotonously ,when all values are bigger than 2. If whatever m is, this equation has only finite solutions(when all are integer), $2\leq m\leq12(n=2,a=2,b=3,c=5)$.


I was able to find a general equation for your second relation with the $4n+1$ primes. For the first relation, discovered by Ramanujan, a general formula can be found here where the variable is $a=3$.

Here is my general solution:

$$\sqrt{\cfrac{n}{n-4}\bigg(1-\cfrac{1}{n^2}\bigg)\bigg\{1-\cfrac{1}{(n-3)^2}\bigg\}\bigg\{1-\cfrac{1}{(2n-3)^2}\bigg\}\bigg\{1-\cfrac{1}{(2n+1)^2}\bigg\}}=\bigg(1+\cfrac{1}{n-3}\bigg)\bigg(1+\cfrac{1}{2n-3}\bigg)\bigg(1+\cfrac{1}{2n+1}\bigg)$$ in which the relation you presented is obtained from $n=8$.

Often Ramanujan's formulae are derived from his incredible intuition. Likewise, I used my intuition and let $a=a_0n+a_1$, $b=b_0n+b_1$ and $c=c_0n+c_1$. I then matched these values to your relation to evaluate each variable around $n$ and solving for $m$ through some heavy algebra, lots of things cancelled out and outputted $m=n/(n-4)$.

If you want a nicer result, substitute $n\mapsto n+2$ so $m=(n+2)/(n-2)$, but then your relation would be obtained by letting $n+2=8\Rightarrow n=6$ instead. Also, in this generalisation, $n=3$ would yield prime denominators.


Found some more general solutions through trial and error:

$$\sqrt{\cfrac{3n+2}{3n-4}\bigg(1-\cfrac{1}{n^2}\bigg)\bigg\{1-\cfrac{1}{(2n+1)^2}\bigg\}\bigg\{1-\cfrac{1}{(3n+1)^2}\bigg\}\bigg\{1-\cfrac{1}{(6n-7)^2}\bigg\}}$$ $$=\bigg(1+\cfrac{1}{2n+1}\bigg)\bigg(1+\cfrac{1}{3n+1}\bigg)\bigg(1+\cfrac{1}{6n-7}\bigg)$$

Even when $m$ is a square number! $\;\style{display: inline-block; transform: rotate(90deg)}{\Rsh}$

$$\bigg(1+\cfrac 1{n-1}\bigg)\sqrt{\bigg(1-\cfrac{1}{n^2}\bigg)\bigg\{1-\cfrac{1}{(2n+1)^2}\bigg\}\bigg\{1-\cfrac{1}{(3n-1)^2}\bigg\}\bigg\{1-\cfrac{1}{(6n-5)^2}\bigg\}}$$ $$=\bigg(1+\cfrac{1}{2n+1}\bigg)\bigg(1+\cfrac{1}{3n-1}\bigg)\bigg(1+\cfrac{1}{6n-5}\bigg)$$ and $$\bigg(1+\cfrac 1{n-1}\bigg)\sqrt{\bigg(1-\cfrac{1}{n^2}\bigg)\bigg\{1-\cfrac{1}{(2n+1)^2}\bigg\}\bigg\{1-\cfrac{1}{(3n-2)^2}\bigg\}\bigg\{1-\cfrac{1}{(6n-1)^2}\bigg\}}$$ $$=\bigg(1+\cfrac{1}{2n+1}\bigg)\bigg(1+\cfrac{1}{3n-2}\bigg)\bigg(1+\cfrac{1}{6n-1}\bigg)$$

as well as an outlier.

$$\sqrt{3\bigg(3+\frac{4}{n-1}\bigg)\bigg(1-\cfrac{1}{n^2}\bigg)\bigg\{1-\cfrac{1}{(2n+1)^2}\bigg\}\bigg\{1-\cfrac{1}{(3n)^2}\bigg\}\bigg\{1-\cfrac{1}{(6n-1)^2}\bigg\}}$$ $$=\bigg(3-\frac 1n\bigg)\bigg(1+\cfrac{1}{2n+1}\bigg)\bigg(1+\cfrac{1}{3n}\bigg)\bigg(1+\cfrac{1}{6n-1}\bigg)$$

And last one, most similar to the main one in the link:

$$\sqrt{\cfrac{n+1}{n-1}\bigg(1-\cfrac{1}{n^2}\bigg)\bigg\{1-\cfrac{1}{(2n+1)^2}\bigg\}\bigg\{1-\cfrac{1}{(3n+1)^2}\bigg\}\bigg\{1-\cfrac{1}{(6n+5)^2}\bigg\}}$$ $$=\bigg(1+\cfrac{1}{2n+1}\bigg)\bigg(1+\cfrac{1}{3n+1}\bigg)\bigg(1+\cfrac{1}{6n+5}\bigg)$$

The magical factor common among all of these solutions: $1+\frac 1{2n+1}$


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.