I've stumbled across a proof of geodesic stability in hyperbolic space, located in the following blog post:


Maybe it would be wiser to comment there directly, but I figured I would ask here first. Is the proof of lemma 5 valid? I am really not convinced of it. I know where to find a proof in the setting of $\delta$-hyperbolic spaces, but it would be nice to use this one since it's quite simple in comparison.

  • $\begingroup$ Can you precise the point you find uncorrect? $\endgroup$ – Seirios Mar 16 '16 at 8:55
  • $\begingroup$ @Seirios I'm not sure about how they're picking the C neighborhood after realizing that the length of sigma is bounded. Or why this really proves the statement. I thought they would try to uniformly bound the image of sigma under the QI (but I guess that could be done by multiply by K and epsilon, as they mention). Also the preceding lemma isn't convincing either, but that might be a separate issue. $\endgroup$ – Hanna Mar 16 '16 at 15:31

Let $f : \mathbb{H}^n \to \mathbb{H}^n$ be a $(k,\epsilon)$-quasi-isometry and let $[p,q]$ denote the unique geodesic between two points $p,q \in \mathbb{H}^n$.

  • Step 1: Fix some $C$ satisfying $k^2e^{-C} <1$.

  • Step 2: If $[r,s] \subset [p,q]$ is a maximal subsegment such that $f([r,s])$ is outside the $C$-neighborhood of $[p,q]$, then $$d(r,s) \leq \frac{2kC + k \epsilon + k \epsilon e^{-C}}{1-k^2 e^{-C}}.$$

  • Step 3: Let $t \in [p,q]$. If $d(f(t),[f(p),f(q)]) \leq C$ there is nothing to prove, so suppose $d(f(t),[f(p),f(q)]) > C$. Then $t$ belongs a maximal subsegment $[r,s]$ similar to the previous one. Now, $$d(f(t),[f(p),f(q)]) \leq d(f(t),f(r)) + d(f(r),[f(p),f(q)]).$$ But $d(f(r),[f(p),f(q)])=C$ and $$d(f(t),f(r)) \leq k d(t,r)+ \epsilon \leq k d(r,s) + \epsilon \leq k \cdot \frac{2kC + k \epsilon + k \epsilon e^{-C}}{1-k^2 e^{-C}} + \epsilon.$$ Therefore, $d(f(t),[f(p),f(q)])$ is bounded by a constant which depends only on $k$ and $\epsilon$.

  • $\begingroup$ Great, thanks for clarifying this. It makes more sense now! $\endgroup$ – Hanna Mar 18 '16 at 20:25

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.