$8$ cards are drawn without replacement from an ordinary deck. Find the probability of obtaining exactly $3$ aces, or exactly $3$ kings, or both.

The answer is $\frac{2~\binom 4 3 \binom {48} 5 - \binom 4 3 \binom 4 3\binom {44} 2 }{ \binom {52} 8 }$

I am trying hard to understand the reasoning behind this answer but still don't fully get it

Can someone explain please. Thank you very much.

please read $\binom m n$ as "from m pick n"

Things I believe I understand:

$\binom {52} 8\,\leftarrow$ obvious. # of possible different 8 card hands

$2~\binom 4 3 \binom {48} 5\,\leftarrow$ the act of taking 3 figures of the same rank (be it aces or kings) and multiplying it by the way in which the 5 remaining cards can be chosen.

Thanks again.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ No thank you. I will read it as '$m$ choose $n$' :) $\endgroup$ – Em. Feb 26 '16 at 0:09
  • $\begingroup$ @probablyme why you didn't suggest an answer? $\endgroup$ – Prefijo Sustantivo Feb 26 '16 at 21:42

It's the principle of inclusion and exclusion at work.

$$\mathsf P(A\cup K) = \mathsf P(A)+\mathsf P(K)-\mathsf P(A\cap K)$$

$\mathsf P(A)~=~{\binom 4 3\binom {48} 5}\big/{\binom {52} 8}$ is the probability of obtaining 3 aces and 5 non-aces.   Some of those 5 non-aces may be kings.

$\mathsf P(K)~=~{\binom 4 3\binom {48} 5}\big/{\binom {52} 8}$ is the probability of obtaining 3 kings and 5 non-kings.   Some of those 5 non-kings may be aces.

$\mathsf P(A\cap K)~=~{\binom 4 3\binom 4 3\binom {44} 2}\big/{\binom {52} 8}$ is the probability of obtaining 3 aces, 3 kings, and 2 cards of other faces.   However we've counted this event among both the above.   So to avoid over counting we subtract one occurrence.

$$\mathsf P(A\cup K) = \dfrac{\binom 4 3\binom {48} 5 + \binom 4 3\binom {48} 5- \binom 4 3\binom 4 3\binom {44} 2}{\binom {52} 8}$$

That is all.



The number of hands of 8 cards with exactly 3 kings is:

  • a group of 3 kings taken from 4 possible kings i.e. $\binom{4}{3}=4$ multiplied by
  • a group of 5 cards that are not kings taken from $52-4=48$ possible cards i.e. $\binom{48}{5}$

The number of hands of 8 cards with exactly 3 aces is the same that the number of cards with exactly 3 kings.

But in any case we counted the number of both, 3 kings and 3 aces, so the number of hands with 3 kings and 3 aces are counted twice so we must subtract one time this quantity (this is a case of inclusion-exclusion principle).

The number of hands with exactly 3 kings and 3 aces is $\binom{4}{3}^2\binom{44}{2}$.

And all possible hands of 8 cards are $\binom{52}{8}$, so the probability will be:



Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.