I have two equations:

  1. $x = \sqrt{16}$
  2. $x^2 = 16$

In first case I think there will be two value of $x = \pm4$. Because $(-4) \cdot (-4) =( +4) \cdot(+4) = 16$

In the second case I am confused. It can also have two values i.e $\pm 4$.

But somewhere I read that one of the equations returns only one value and it will be $+4$. I can't find which one will return $+4$ and which one both values and the reason behind it. Can any body help me please? Thanks.

  • $\begingroup$ In the second case, $x$ is a "Square Root" of $16$. In the first case, $x$ is the "Principle Square Root" of $16$. The "Principle Square Root" is always non-negative. I suppose that the negative square root would be called the "Secondary Square Root" or perhaps the "Conjugate Square Root"??? $\endgroup$
    – John Joy
    Dec 15, 2015 at 23:27

3 Answers 3


Square root is a mathematical function and as any other function it must have only one value for any given argument.

$f(x)=\sqrt{x}$ has one and only one value for $x=16$ if $\sqrt{x}$ is to be defined at all.

Normally, we talk about branches when we deal with multivalued regions.

If we understand $f(x)=\sqrt{x}$ as the inverse of $f(x)=x^{2}$, we have two branches: $x>0$ and $x<0$. $x>0$ is called principal branch and this one is assumed if nothing else is specified for $f(x)=\sqrt{x}$. Since $x=0$ may belong to both branches we extend the region to $x \ge 0$.

From this perspective $x=\sqrt{16}$ is an assignment or identity, depending on the context, the same as $x=4$. However, $x^2=16$ is an equation that needs to be solved, with $x$ being the unknown. In the case of $x=\sqrt{16}$, $x$ is not an unknown.

  1. $x = \sqrt{16} = 4 \neq -4$

  2. $x^2 = 16 \iff x= \pm\sqrt{16} = \pm 4$

Your reasoning for the first case actually deals with the second case. In general for $x>0$ we always have $\sqrt{x} > 0$.


The square root symbol when applied to a positive real number $r$ is defined to be the positive value whose square is $r$. That's not something you can say is right or wrong, it's just a definition.

In contrast if we ask for all values $x$ that solve the equation $x^2=16$ then there are two values of $x$ that work, $x=4$ and $x=-4$.

You see, equations can have more than one solution.

In other words in one case we have the common definition of a symbol, which must have a single value, while in the other case we are asking for the solutions of an equation which can be multiple values.


You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .