Let $G$ be a permutation group acting transitively on some set $\Omega$ and suppose we have a normal subgroup $N \unlhd G$. Then the orbits of $N$ form a system of blocks, and if $\Delta$ is such an $N$-orbit, then for its setwise stabilizer $$ G_{\{\Delta\}} = \{ g \in G : \Delta^g = \Delta \} $$ we have $G_{\{\Delta\}} = G_{\alpha}N$ for some $\alpha \in \Delta$. As $\Delta = \alpha^N$ the inclusion $G_{\alpha}N \le G_{\{\Delta\}}$ is clear, for the other inclusion note that if $\Delta^g = \Delta$, then $\alpha^g = \alpha^n$, hence $g \in G_{\alpha}\cdot n$. Now $G$ acts on the $N$-orbits, as they form a system of blocks, and the kernel of this action is $$ \bigcap_{\Delta \mbox{ some $N$-orbit}} G_{\{\Delta\}} = \bigcap_{\alpha \in \Omega} G_{\alpha} N. $$

Do we have $$ \bigcap_{\alpha\in \Omega} G_{\alpha} N = N? $$

Surely as the action is faithful we have $\bigcap_{\alpha \in \Omega} G_{\alpha} = 1$, and we have $g \in \bigcap_{\alpha\in \Omega} G_{\alpha} N$ iff $$ \forall \alpha \in \Omega \exists n \in N : \alpha^g = \alpha^n $$ i.e. for each $\alpha \in \Omega$ we have that $\alpha^g$ lies in the same $N$-orbits as $\alpha$.


We do not necessarily have that the kernel of the action on blocks is equal to $N$.

A small counterexample is $D_8$ (or $D_4$ if you prefer!) = $\langle (1,2,3,4),(2,4) \rangle \le S_4$. Let $N=Z(G) = \langle (1,3)(2,4) \rangle$, which has two orbits of length $2$. The kernel of the action on blocks has order $4$ and is $\langle (1,3), (2,4) \rangle$.

Note that in this example the kernel is equal to the block stabilizer $NG_1$.

Of course you get more obvious counterexamples in which $N$ is transitive, and then the kernel of the action is the whole of $G$.

| cite | improve this answer | |
  • $\begingroup$ Thanks you for your example. I would also like to add that the point stabilizers $G_1 = G_3 = \langle (2 ~ 4) \rangle, G_2 = G_4 = \langle (1 ~ 3) \rangle$ have trivial intersection, so this would not be a sufficient condition to imply that precisely $N$ is the kernel. $\endgroup$ – StefanH Dec 8 '15 at 16:24

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.