Can every monad give rise to a monad transformer?

In the paper Calculating monad transformers with category theory by Oleksandr Manzyuk, one finds a construction of monad transformers as translating monads along adjunctions. In particular, considering the Eilenberg-Moore construction, we can translate the monads on the category $C^T$ of $T$-algebras to monads on the original category $C,$ where $T$ is the monad we start from. Hence, if somehow a monad on $C$ induces a monad on $C^T,$ then we can translate that induced monad along the adjunction between $C$ and $C^T$ that defines $T.$ Since we can regard $C^T$ as a subcategory of $C,$ we know that there is indeed an induction if every monad $M$ on $C$ maps $T$-algebras to $T$-algebras, e.g. if $T$ commutes with all monads; in particular, the Writer-monad-transformers can be derived this way. But I know almost nothing about the center of the category $\text{Mon}(C)$ of monads on $C,$ which is equivalent to the category of monoids in the functor category $C^C=\text{Hom}(C, C).$

Then I found this question on MSE, from which I see that the functor $T\rightarrow\text{Ran}_{F^T}(F^TT)$ is a lax monoidal functor, hence inducing a functor $\text{Mon}(C)\rightarrow\text{Mon}(C^T),$ where $F^T$ is the left adjoint functor to the forgetful functor $U^T:C^T\rightarrow C.$ So the question becomes

When will the right Kan extension $\text{Ran}_{F^T}(F^TT)$ exist?
Does the construction ($T\rightarrow \text{Ran}_{F^T}(F^TT)\rightarrow\text{translating along }F^T$) give the right notion of monad transformers?

This question sounds quite obscure and confusing, but all I want to know is that are there general constructions of monad transformers for any given monad?

Any answer or reference will be sincerely appreciated, and thanks in advance.


Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.