Let $S/\mathbb{C}$ be a smooth projective surface and let $C/\mathbb{C}$ be a smooth projective curve such that there exists a surjective morphism $\pi: S \to C$. Are the following conditions equivalent and if so, why?

  1. The generic fibre $S_\eta \to \text{Spec}(\mathbb{C}(C))$ is a (smooth) genus 1 curve.
  2. For all but finitely many closed points $P$ of $C$, the fibre $S_P$ is an elliptic curve.

Yes if you suppose $O_C\to \pi_*O_S$ is an isomorphism. By the generic smoothness, we know that all fibers are smooth except for a proper closed subset of (so finitely many points in) $C$. Moreover, as $\pi$ is flat, the fibers have the same arithmetic genus. The hypothesis on $\pi_*O_S$ implies that all fibers are connected (Zariski's connectedness theorem). So for smooth fibers, arithmetic genus equal to geometric genus.

(1) implies (2): if the generic fiber has genus 1, then all smooth fibers are curves of genus $1$ over $\mathbb C$, so they are elliptic curves.

(2) implies (1): if one fiber is elliptic, then the generic fiber has genus $1$.

Without the hypothesis on $\pi_*O_S$, the implication from (1) to (2) is not true: consider a non trivial cover $C' \to C$, a surface $S$ fibered over $C'$ and compose $S\to C'\to C$. Then most of the fibers of $S\to C$ are not connected and therefore are not elliptic curves.

Edit the counterexample may not be one, it depends on what you call a genus $1$ curve. If it is geometrically connected, then (1) implies the condition on $\pi_*O_S$ and hence (2). On the other hand, the method of the "counterexample" shows that (2) implies (1) (and $O_C\simeq\pi_*O_S$).


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.