4
$\begingroup$

Let $ G $ be a solvable primitive permutation group. Why the degree of $ G $ is a prime power and $ G $ has a unique minimal normal subgroup? (8B.4 problem of Finite group theory by Issac) Is transitive this minimal normal subgroup of $ G $?

$\endgroup$
  • 5
    $\begingroup$ Any nontrivial normal subgroup of any primitive permutation group is transitive. And abelian transitive groups are regular, and self-centralizing in the symmetric group, so all of the statements follow. $\endgroup$ – Derek Holt Oct 15 '15 at 8:08
3
$\begingroup$

Allow me to give a reference, make the statement more precise, expand Derek's answer, and state a converse.

The theorem actually goes back to Galois himself. A nice historical account can be found in

Peter Neumann, The concept of primitivity in group theory and the Second Memoir of Galois, Arch. Hist. Exact Sci. 60 (2006) 4, 379--429.

Let $G$ be a transitive subgroup of the group of permutations $\mathfrak{S}_\Omega$ of a finite set $\Omega$. Then, as a $G$-set, $\Omega$ is isomorphic to the $G$-set $G/H$ for some subgroup $H$ of $G$, uniquely determined up to conjugation by an element of $G$. The permutation group $G$ is said to be primitive if the subgroup $H$ is maximal in $G$ (in the sense that $H\neq G$ and the only subgroups of $G$ containing $H$ are $G$ and $H$).

Recall also the notion of a torsor for a group $\Gamma$. It simply means a transitive (and hence nonempty) $\Gamma$-set for which stabilisers of points are trivial. If $\Gamma$ is a vector space of dimension $n$ over a field $k$, then a $\Gamma$-torsor $E$ is also called an affine $n$-space over $k$, and $\Gamma$ is said to be the space of translations of $E$.

Here is how I like to formulate the statement :

Theorem (Galois). If $\,G$ is a solvable primitive subgroup of $\,\mathfrak{S}_\Omega$, then there is a unique structure on $\,\Omega$ of an affine $n$-space over $\mathbf{F}_l$ (for some prime $l$ and some $n>0$) such that $$ N\subset G\subset\mathrm{AGL}(\Omega)\subset\mathfrak{S}_\Omega, $$ where $N$ (resp. $\mathrm{AGL}(\Omega)$) is the space of translations (resp. the group of automorphisms or invertible affine maps) of the affine space $\Omega$.

Proof. Let $N$ be a minimal normal subgroup of $G$. Since $G$ is solvable, $N$ is a vector $n$-space over $\mathbf{F}_l$ for some prime $l$ and some $n>0$. Since $G$ is primitive, $N$ is transitive. Since $N$ is commutative and transitive, $\Omega$ is an $N$-torsor. Finally, one checks that $G$ acts on $\Omega$ by affine maps (because the conjugation action of $G/N$ on $N$ is by $\mathbf{F}_l$-linear maps, automatically). It follows from this that the degree of $G$ is $l^n$.

Conversely,

Theorem. Let $\Omega$ be an affine space over $\mathbf{F}_l$ of dimension $n>0$ and let $N$ be its space of translations. An intermediate group $N\subset G\subset\mathrm{AGL}(\Omega)$ is solvable (resp. primitive) if and only if $G/N$ is solvable (resp. the $\mathbf{F}_l[G/N]$-module $N$ is simple).

Proof. The bit about solvability is clear. Suppose that $G$ is imprimitive, and let $(\Omega_i)_{i\in I}$ be a $G$-stable partition of $\Omega$ (with $1<|I|<l^n$). Since $G$ is transitive (even $N$ is transitive), the parts $\Omega_i$ have the same cardinal $l^m$, for some $m\in[1,n[$. One checks that they are affine subspaces, all parallel to each other. Their common direction $M\subset N$ is a $G$-stable subspace of dimension $m$, so $N$ is not simple as an $\mathbf{F}_l[G/N]$-module. Conversely, if the $\mathbf{F}_l[G/N]$-module $N$ is not simple, let $M\subset N$ be a $G$-stable subspace of some dimension $m\in[1,n[$. The family of affine subspaces of $\Omega$ of direction $M$ is a $G$-stable partition of $\Omega$ (having $l^{n-m}$ parts), so $G$ is imprimitive.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.