I am now reading the book by Blyth, 'Module thery---an approach to linear algebra'.

I do not understand such a paragraph with which he motivates the learning of module theory:

In many ways, however, the notion of a vector space is too restrictive. Perhaps one way we can illustrate this is by asking the following question: has it occurred to the reader that, in most elementary introductions to linear algebra, determinants are defined for square matrices whose entries belong to a given field yet, come the consideration of eigenvalues, the matrix whose determinant has to be found has its entries in a polynomial ring? Put another way, should the various properties of determinants not really be developed in a more general setting?

Can anyone explain it in detail?


1 Answer 1


The eigenvalues of a matrix $A$ over a field $k$ are the roots of the characteristic polynomial $\chi(A)=\det(\lambda I-A)$. But what is this thing we're taking the determinant of? $\lambda$ is not an element of $k$, but an indeterminate, so to properly describe $\lambda I-A$ we ought to say its coefficients, e.g. $2-\lambda$, are elements of the polynomial ring $k[\lambda]$. So this is an example of a determinant of a matrix with entries from a ring that's not a field.

  • $\begingroup$ If you perhaps forgot that the integers can be embedded in the reals, you can make this same point by trying to take the determinant of a matrix with integer entries, right? $\endgroup$
    – Gus
    Oct 19, 2016 at 18:39

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .