Let $(X,d_X)$ and $(Y,d_Y)$ be metric spaces, and consider the product metric space $(X\times Y,d)$ with a product metric $d$.

Let $f(x,y):X\times Y\to \mathbb{R}$ be a separately continuous function.

Suppose $X$: compact.

Is $g(y)=\sup\limits_{x\in X}f(x,y)$ continuous?

What if $Y$ is also compact?

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Suppose $X$ is not compact. Then, it fails even when $f$ is (jointly) continuous. A counter example is given http://at.yorku.ca/cgi-bin/bbqa?forum=ask_an_analyst_2005&task=show_msg&msg=4110.0001. That $x$ can go as far as possible does bad.

Another counter example where $X$ is not compact is Supremum of continuous functions is continuous?.

Suppose $X$ and $Y$ are compact, and $f$ is (jointly) continuous. Following the argument here: How prove this $g(x)=\sup{\{f(x,y)|0\le y\le 1\}}$ is continuous on $[0,1]$ it seems to hold, using $f$ being uniformly continuous on $X\times Y$.

Go back to my question. In this case, we cannot use the uniform continuity. I tried doing the following and got stuck. From the compactness of $X$ and continuity in $x$, we can take $x^*_j\in\mathrm{argmax}_x f(x,y_j)$, ($j=1,2$), and $$ |g(y_1)-g(y_2)|\le |f(x_1^*,y_1)-f(x_1^*,y_2)|+|f(x_1^*,y_2)-f(x_2^*,y_2)|. $$ The first term is good as $f(x_1^*,\cdot)$ is continuous, but I could not do anything with the second term, and started to think maybe this is not true.


Here is a counterexample.

Take $f\colon [0,1]\times[0,1]\to \mathbb R$ defined by: $$ f(x,y) = \frac{2xy}{x^2+y^2},\quad f(0,0)=0. $$ Notice that $2xy = x^2 + y^2 - (x-y)^2 \le x^2+y^2$ hence $f(x,y)\le 1$. While $f(y,y) = 1$.

Of course $f$ is separately continuous, but for $y>0$ one has: $$ \sup_x f(x,y) = f(y,y) = 1 $$ while $f(x,0)=0$ hence $\sup_x f(x,0) = 0$.


This is not true in general. As a counterexample, I will use the compact space $X = \overline {\Bbb {N}}=\Bbb {N}\cup \{\infty\} $, the one point compactification of $\Bbb{N} $.

If we have a sequence of functions $(f_n)_n $ defined on any metric space $Y $ (we will consider $Y=[0,1] $) with $f_n (y)\to 0$ for all $y\in Y $ and if each $f_n $ is continuous, then $$ F : X\times Y \to \Bbb {R}, (n,y)\mapsto \begin {cases} f_n (y),&y \in \Bbb {N}\\0,&y=\infty \end {cases} $$ is separately continuous. It suffices to find such a sequence, so that $$ y\mapsto g (y):=\sup_{x \in X} F (x,y)=\sup_{n \in \Bbb {N}} f_n (y) $$ Is not continuous.

To this end, let $ f_n :[0,1]\to \Bbb {R} $ be affinely linear on the intervals $[0,1/n], [1/n,2/n] $ with $f_n (0)=0$, $f_n (1/n)=1$, $f_n (2/n)=0$ and $f_n (y)=0$ for $y \geq 2/n $ (draw a picture!).

Then all properties from above are satisfied, but we have $g (0)=0$, while $g (1/n)\geq 1$ for all $n $. Thus, $g $ is not continuous.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.