This is a homework problem I've been bashing my head against:

Consider a disjoint union of topological spaces $Z_i$ with the disjoint union topology, $$ Z = \bigsqcup_{i \in I} Z_i $$ Let $f:\ Z \twoheadrightarrow A$ be a surjection, and put the quotient topology generated by $f$ on $A$.

Prove that $U \subseteq A$ is open in $A$ $\iff$ for every $i \in I$, $U \cap f \left( Z_i \right)$ is open in $A$.

Here is what I've proven so far: (This may or may not be useful.)

  • $U \subseteq Z$ is open (closed) in $Z$ $\iff$ for every $i \in I$, $U \cap Z_i$ is open (closed) in $Z$.

  • The $( \Leftarrow )$ implication is fairly easy; if each $U \cap f \left( Z_i \right)$ is open, then we can write $U$ as a union of open sets: $U = \bigcup_{i \in I} U \cap f \left( Z_i \right)$. This implies that $U$ is open since topologies are closed under arbitrary unions.

  • The function $f$ is continuous just by definition of the quotient topology. ($U \subseteq A$ is open in $A \iff$ $f^{-1} \left( U \right)$ is open in $Z$.)

Now here's a problem: Consider $Z_1 = [0,\ 1]$, $Z_2 = [1,\ 2]$ with subspace topology inherited from the standard topology on $\mathbb{R}$. Let $f$ map $Z_1$ to $[0,\ 1]$ and $Z_2$ to $[1,\ 2]$. Identify the point $1$ in $Z_1$ and $Z_2$ as the same point in the quotient space $A = [0,\ 2]$. The function $f$ is essentially an identity map that glues the two intervals together, and is obviously surjective.

Now take $U = (1- \epsilon,\ 1+ \epsilon)$ for some small $\epsilon >0$. $U$ is open in $A$, since it's the image of the saturated open set $(1- \epsilon,\ 1] \cup [1,\ 1 + \epsilon)$. (This is open in $Z$ since it's a union of an open set in $Z_1$ and an open set in $Z_2$.)

Now $f \left( Z_1 \right) = [0,\ 1]$. This is not open in $A$ to the best of my knowledge, since $f^{-1} \left( f \left( Z_1 \right) \right) = Z_1 \cup \{ 1^\prime \}$, where $1^\prime \in Z_2$ is understood as different from the element $1 \in Z_1$, is not open in $Z$. Then $U \cap f \left( Z_1 \right) = (1-\epsilon,\ 1]$. This is not open in $A$.

What is the error in my reasoning here?


There is no error in your reasoning: the statement in the exercise is false.

No need to take $\epsilon$ very small: you can simply let $U=(0,2)$. There is a small error, presumably a typo, in your last paragraph: $f^{-1}\big[f[Z_1]\big]=Z_1\cup\{1'\}$, not $A\cup\{1'\}$. Indeed, you can show that $A$ that has its usual Euclidean subspace topology, so $U\cap f[Z_1]=(0,1]$ is certainly not open in $A$.

  • $\begingroup$ Thanks for that typo catch! $\endgroup$
    – Roger Burt
    Sep 17 '15 at 6:51
  • $\begingroup$ @Roger: You’re welcome! $\endgroup$ Sep 17 '15 at 6:51

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.