Page 113 - Dummit and Foote - Group actions

Two group elements induce the same permutation on $A$ if and only if they are in the same coset of the kernel.

What does this mean? Two permutations induce the same permutation on $A$ looks like it means $\sigma_1 A = A' = \sigma_2 A$ and then I don't really understand the right hand side of the $\iff$.

  • $\begingroup$ Could you provide more context? What group action are you dealing with and which kernel is meant here? $\endgroup$ – Stefan Hamcke Aug 12 '15 at 7:35
  • $\begingroup$ @StefanHamcke I don't know what is relevant context unfortunately, it just came up in D&F and I had read all the previous parts of the chapter, that seem unrelated $\endgroup$ – Galois in the Field Aug 12 '15 at 9:11

This is my understanding of the text:

Let group $G$ act on $A$ as $g.a$ $\forall g \in G$ and $a\in A$

Let $\phi: G \to S_A$ be the associated permutation representation (homomorphism)

Let $K$ be the kernel of this map, which is also the kernel of the group action.

Then according to me, the text says

$\phi(g)= \phi(h) \iff gK = hK$


$$ \iff \phi(g)(a)=\phi(h)(a)\; \forall a\in A$$

$$\iff g.a=h.a \; \;\forall a \in A$$

$$\iff h^{-1}.(g.a)= (h^{-1}).(h.a) \; \; \forall a \in A$$

$$\iff (h^{-1}g).a=(h^{-1}h).a=1.a=a \; \;\forall a \in A$$

$$\iff h^{-1}g \in K$$

$$\iff gK = hK$$


Okay so $A$ is a set being acted upon by a group $G$ (as a group of permutations); the kernel of the action of $G$ on $A$ is defined to be the subgroup fixing $A$, that is the elements $\phi$ such that $a^{\phi} = a$ for all $a \in A$.

Now, suppose that $\sigma_{1}$, $\sigma_{2} \in G$ with $a^{\sigma_{1}} = a^{\sigma_{2}}$ for all $a \in A$ (this is what it means for them to induce the same permutation on $A$)? What can we say about $a^{\sigma_{1} \sigma_{2}^{-1}}$?

On the other hand, suppose we have $\phi$ in the kernel of the action, so $a^{\phi} = a$ for all $a \in A$; what can we say about $a^{\sigma}$ and $a^{\phi \sigma} = (a^{\phi})^{\sigma}$?

(I prefer this exponent notation for group actions, because it makes it clear that $a$ is not considered as an element of $G$, rather it is some object that the elements of $G$ act on.)


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.