Consider the cyclotomic field $\mathbb{Q}(\zeta_{12})$ where $\zeta_{12}$ represents the $12$-th primitive root of unity. Since the minimal polynomial of $\zeta_{12}$ is given by $\Phi_{12}(x)$ which has degree $4$, we have that, $$ [ \mathbb{Q}(\zeta_{12}) : \mathbb{Q} ] =4$$ And so I would think that $$ a + b \zeta_{12} + c \zeta_{12}^2 + d \zeta_{12}^3$$ would be a basis for $\mathbb{Q}(\zeta_{12})$.

Now consider the isomorphism that maps $5 \in (\mathbb{Z}_{12})^{\times}$ to $\rho_5 (\zeta_{12}) = \zeta_{12}^5$.

I compute the following, $$\rho_5 (a + b \zeta_{12} + c \zeta_{12}^2 + d \zeta_{12}^3) = a + b \zeta_{12}^5 + \zeta_{12}^{10} + \zeta_{12}^{15}= a + b \zeta_{12} + c \zeta_{12}^2 + d \zeta_{12}^3$$

I'm taking the exponents to be modulo $4$.

I don't think my calculation is correct since this isomorphism should not fix the entire field by Galois Theory. What am I doing wrong ?


What makes you think that $$a + b \zeta_{12}^5 + c\zeta_{12}^{10} + d\zeta_{12}^{15}= a + b \zeta_{12} + c \zeta_{12}^2 + d \zeta_{12}^3$$ is true? The powers of $\zeta_{12}$ repeat modulo 12. In fact since the $12$th cyclotomic polynomial is $\Phi_{12}=x^4-x^2+1$, we have that $$\begin{align*} \zeta_{12}^5&=\zeta_{12}^5+0\\\\ &=\zeta_{12}^5+(-\zeta_{12})\underbrace{(\zeta_{12}^4-\zeta_{12}^2+1)}_{0}\\ &=\zeta_{12}^3-\zeta_{12} \end{align*}$$ and by a similar computation, we can find that $\zeta_{12}^{10}=-\zeta_{12}^2+1$. Lastly, since the powers of $\zeta_{12}$ repeat modulo 12, we have $$\zeta_{12}^{15}=\zeta_{12}^{12}\cdot \zeta_{12}^3=1\cdot \zeta_{12}^3=\zeta_{12}^3$$ Thus the correct decomposition in the basis $\{1,\zeta_{12},\zeta_{12}^2,\zeta_{12}^3\}$ is $$a + b \zeta_{12}^5 + c\zeta_{12}^{10} + d\zeta_{12}^{15}= (a+c) - b \zeta_{12} - c \zeta_{12}^2 + (b+d) \zeta_{12}^3$$


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.