I'm studying calculus from Rogawski's Calculus. In trigonometric substitution $x=a\sec \theta$ he made a note:

In the substitution $x = a \sec θ$ , we choose $0\le θ \le π$ 2 if $x \ge a$ and $π \le θ < \frac{3π}2$ if $x \le −a$. With these choices, $a \tan \theta$ is the positive square root $\sqrt{x^2 − a^2}$.

When I work on the integral:

$$\int \frac {\mathrm{d}x}{x\sqrt{x^2-9}}$$ Using the substitution of $x=3\sec\theta$ with the domain of $\theta$ shown above, the integration will be : $$\int \frac {dx}{x\sqrt{x^2-9}}= \int \frac {3\sec\theta\tan\theta d\theta}{(3\sec\theta)\sqrt{9\sec^2-9}}=\int \frac {\tan\theta d\theta}{3\sqrt{\tan^2 \theta}}$$ $$= \int \frac{d\theta}{3}= \frac\theta 3+ \mathrm{C}$$

$$\int \frac {dx}{x\sqrt{x^2-9}}= \frac 13 \sec^{-1}\left(\frac x3\right)+ \mathrm{C}$$

Which is very wrong in the negative part of the domain of $x$ as shown in this graph:

enter image description here Notice that the slope of the blue function in the negative domain should be positive not negative!.

The problem of this substitution is $2$ things:

$1)$ The domain of $\theta$ is chosen so that inverse cannot be done, since $\theta =\sec^{-1}x\notin (\pi,\frac{3\pi}2) $ which is the domain chosen for $\theta $.

$2)$ Depending on first problem, we should choose $\theta \in (0,\pi)-\{\frac\pi 2\}$ which makes $\sqrt{\tan^2 \theta}=|\tan \theta|$. The integral then should be re-written as a piecewise function:

$$\int \frac {dx}{x\sqrt{x^2-9}}= \int \frac {3\sec\theta\tan\theta d\theta}{(3\sec\theta)\sqrt{9\sec^2-9}}$$

$$\int \frac {\tan\theta d\theta}{3\sqrt{\tan^2 \theta}} = \begin{cases} = \int \frac {d\theta}{3} = \frac 13 \sec^{-1}(\frac x3)+ C & \text{if $\theta \in (0,\frac \pi 2)$} \equiv x>3 \\= \int \frac {-d\theta}{3} = \frac {-1}3 \sec^{-1}(\frac x3)+ C & \text{if $\theta \in (\frac \pi 2,\pi)$}\equiv x<-3 \end{cases}$$

My questions are:

Is this thinking right ? there is mistake to choose the domain of $\theta$ as mentioned in the book ?

Mathematica gives me the answer of $-\dfrac {1}{3} \tan^{-1} \left(\dfrac{3}{\sqrt{x^2-9}}\right) +\mathrm{C}$ which is right when graphed. But how to construct this integral ?

Thanks for help.

  • $\begingroup$ How does your text define the range of the inverse secant function? Some authors use $[0,\frac{\pi}{2})\cup(\frac{\pi}{2},\pi]$, while others use $[0,\frac{\pi}{2})\cup[\pi,\frac{3\pi}{2})$. $\endgroup$
    – user84413
    Jul 20 '15 at 0:25
  • $\begingroup$ I checked it and found $[0,\frac{\pi}{2})\cup(\frac{\pi}{2},\pi]$! $\endgroup$ Jul 20 '15 at 17:32
  • $\begingroup$ Thanks for your reply. (There are advantages to either choice, and your thinking is correct with this definition.) $\endgroup$
    – user84413
    Jul 20 '15 at 17:50
  • $\begingroup$ Thanks to you, I searched this problem and found rich writing about it :) $\endgroup$ Jul 20 '15 at 17:51

To get to the answer Mathematica gives, you can let$$ u = \sqrt{x^2 -9}.$$ You should get $$ \frac{1}{3} \arctan \left( \frac{\sqrt{x^2-9}}{3} \right) + \text{constant} $$ and use the fact that $$\arctan(\frac{1}{x}) = \frac{\pi}{2} - \arctan(x)~~~,x\gt 0$$ and $$\arctan(\frac{1}{x}) = -\frac{\pi}{2} - \arctan(x)~~~,x\lt 0 $$

  • $\begingroup$ I got it. Thanks a lot :) $\endgroup$ Jul 19 '15 at 5:54

In the substitution $x = a \sec\theta$ , we choose $0 \leq \theta < \frac\pi2$ if $x \geq a$ and $\pi \leq \theta < \frac{3\pi}2$ if $x \leq −a$. With these choices, $a \tan\theta$ is the positive square root $\sqrt{x^2 − a^2}$.

I think what Rogawski may have in mind here is that $x = a \sec\theta$ is not quite the same thing as $\theta = \sec^{-1}\left( \frac xa \right)$. Since $\sec (-\theta) = \sec\theta$, the possible solutions for $x = a \sec\theta$ are:

$$\theta = \sec^{-1}\left( \frac xa \right) + 2n\pi \quad \text{or} \quad \theta = -\sec^{-1}\left( \frac xa \right) + 2n\pi, \quad \text{where $n \in \mathbb Z$.}$$

If $x \geq a > 0$, so that Rogawski's advice is to let $0 \leq \theta < \frac\pi2$, then $\frac xa \geq 1$ and the "positive" solution with $n = 0$ produces a value of $\theta$ in the correct interval:

$$0 \leq \theta = \sec^{-1}\left( \frac xa \right) < \frac\pi2.$$

But keep in mind that the range of $\sec^{-1}$ is $\left[0, \frac\pi2\right) \cup \left(\frac\pi2, \pi\right]$. If $x \leq -a < 0$, so that Rogawski's advice gives $\pi \leq \theta < \frac{3\pi}2$, then $\frac xa \leq -1$ and the "positive" solution with $n=0$ can give only values of $\theta$ in the interval $\left(\frac\pi2, \pi\right]$, not $\left[\pi, \frac{3\pi}2\right)$. And any other value of $n$ produces a value of theta even farther from the desired interval. The only way to produce a value in the desired interval, $\left[\pi, \frac{3\pi}2\right)$, is to take the "negative" solution with $n = 1$:

$$\pi \leq \theta = -\sec^{-1}\left( \frac xa \right) + 2\pi < \frac{3\pi}2,$$

which you can verify after observing that in this case (with $\frac xa < -1$), $-\pi \leq -\sec^{-1}\left( \frac xa \right) < -\frac\pi2$.

So the correct subsitution (and reverse substitution) is

$$\int \frac {dx}{x\sqrt{x^2-9}} = \int \frac {d\theta}{3} = \frac \theta 3 + C = \begin{cases} \dfrac13 \sec^{-1}\left( \dfrac x3 \right) + C & \text{if }\ x \geq 3, \\ -\dfrac13 \sec^{-1}\left( \dfrac x3 \right) + C & \text{if }\ x < -3. \end{cases}$$ (Note that the constant $2\pi$ in the "negative" case is incorporated in the constant of integration, $C$.)

This is the same result you got by setting $\theta \in \left[0, \frac\pi2\right) \cup \left(\frac\pi2, \pi\right]$ and using the fact that $\sqrt{\tan^2 \theta} = |\tan\theta\,|$. Personally, I see nothing wrong with your method; in fact it may be easier to keep track of the need to do a "sign change" for the integral when $x \leq -3$ when you have an explicit invocation of the absolute value function, $|\tan\theta\,|$, rather than rules that implicitly change the sign of $\sec^{-1}\theta$ (that is, the requirement that $\pi \leq \theta < \frac{3\pi}2$, whose application seems a bit obscure to me).

In short, both methods give the same result, which is the correct result, but only if applied exactly as required at every step. Your method seems less prone to error than the method Rogawski recommends, so everything considered, I think I prefer yours.

(Of course if you are currently taking a class in calculus and have to write solutions of integrals like this on homework or exams, it's a good policy to write your solution in a way that will be easy for the grader to grade correctly. So if you use a technique not shown in class or in the textbook, make sure you explain it clearly, like the way you explained that $\sqrt{\tan^2 \theta} = |\tan\theta\,|$. It just makes life easier for everyone in the end.)

  • $\begingroup$ I got it. Thanks a lot :) $\endgroup$ Jul 20 '15 at 17:49

I am not going to answer your problem on the domain part. Instead, I am suggesting an alternate way to integrating the very last integral.


Claim-1) $P = \int { \frac {dx}{\sqrt {1 - x^2}}} = ... = \sin ^{-1} x$.

Let $x = \sin u$. Then, $dx = du$.

∴ $P = \int {\frac {(\cos u)du}{\sqrt {1 - \sin ^2 u}}} = u = \sin ^{-1} x$

[The whole Claim-2 can be ignored. I just don't want to delete it.]

Claim-2) $Q = \int {\frac {dx}{\sqrt {a^2 – x^2}}} = … = \sin ^{-1} \frac {x}{a}$.

Let $x = av$. Then, $dx = (a)dv$.

∴ $Q = \int {\frac {(a)dv}{\sqrt {a^2 – (av)^2}}}$

$ = \int {\frac {dv}{\sqrt {1 - v^2}}}$, which is essentially $P$.

$ = \sin ^{-1} v$

$ = \sin ^{-1} (\frac {x}{a})$

Claim-3) $R = \int {\frac {dx}{x \sqrt {x^2 – a^2}}} = … = \frac {-1}{a} \sin ^{-1} \frac {a}{x}$.

Further edited

Let $w = \frac {a}{x}$. Then, $dx = \frac {(-a) dw}{w^2}$

∴ $R = \int {\frac {-a (dw)/(w^2)}{(a/w) \sqrt {(a/w)^2 - a^2}}}$

$= - \int {\frac {dw}{w \sqrt{(a/w)^2 -a^2}}}$

$= - \int {\frac {dw}{aw \sqrt {(1/w)^2 - 1^2}}}$

$= \frac {-1}{a} \int {\frac {dw}{\sqrt {1^2 - w^2}}}$

$= \frac {-1}{a} P$

$= \frac {-1}{a} \sin ^{-1} w$

$= \frac {-1}{a} \sin ^{-1} \frac {a}{x}$

  • $\begingroup$ I don't understand your answer entirely! $\endgroup$ Jul 19 '15 at 5:55
  • $\begingroup$ will further edit. Takes time. $\endgroup$
    – Mick
    Jul 19 '15 at 6:05
  • $\begingroup$ From where you get that $R = \int {\frac {dx}{x \sqrt {x^2 – a^2}}} = … = \frac {-1}{a} \sin ^{-1} \frac {a}{x}$ !!!??? the result should be ArcSec not ArcSin!!. In addition I can't find your answer helpful for the question! $\endgroup$ Jul 20 '15 at 17:39
  • $\begingroup$ @MohamedMostafa The post has been further edited to clarify the “ … “ part. It also shows the result is NOT ArcSec but ArcSin instead. The purpose of this post is to show that there is an alternate way of finding the said integral. Sorry if that is not helpful. $\endgroup$
    – Mick
    Jul 21 '15 at 4:35
  • $\begingroup$ FYI: The number of edits (>10) raised a system flag. If you foresee the need to do a lot of editing, it may be a good idea to use the sandbox. The reason is that each and every edit "bumps" the thread to the front page. Doing that often annoys many users :-) $\endgroup$ Jul 21 '15 at 4:47

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.