0
$\begingroup$

I am having a hard time understanding why the chain rule works. When going over a theorm, or feature of the maths in general, one starts of with the easiest examples to get to grips with said concept.

So, now I am studying the chain rule for derivatives, where:

$$f(g(x)) = f´(g(x) g´(x).$$

Right then, so the most simple example out there are linear functions, I mean there their own derivatives. Ok, so lets set $f(x)$ and $g(x)$:

$$f(x) = 2x$$

$$g(x) = 3x$$

Well you don't even need the chain rule, it's obviously $6x$, though I wanted to test its legitimacy, so I obtain, via the chain rule, the following:

$$f´(g(x) = 2 (3x) = 6x.$$

$$g'(x) = 3.$$

So $(6x)3 = 18x$. And whilst this IS true, this is not what we get if we take $f(g(x))$, which = $6x$, and if this wasn't a linear equation, then of course, $f(g(x))$ would not be it's own derivative, but since we are, then we know that either

a) I made a mistake, or

b) The chain rule does work.

I doubt it's case (b), I really don't question the validity of the chain rule, as I've seen it applied to non-linear functions, and I am myself have worked with the chain rule for non-linears. However, why is it that in the most simplistic example, the chain rule does not appear to be working? Maybe it's only valid for certain types of functions?

I cannot eliminate the possibility of case (a). That I am wrong, as to be honest it's likely that, but I have taken the liberty of showing that I am capable of applying the chain rule to some non-linear equations:

enter image description here

So, hopefully this adds competence to my question, as it seems to work with powers of x greater than one, yet there seems to be some issues when x is linear.

Edit So, because of the (very appreciated) replies given, my main concern now that I cannot see how how f´(g(x)) could equal 2. My understanding was that f´ = 2, and is being multiplied by g(x) = 3x.

As in the f(x) = x^2, g(x) = x^3 example, I was drawing upon the parallel that f´(x) = 2x, as this is just applying the power rule, where x is x^3 (because g(x) = x^3), so this is just 2x^3.

Anyway, from that, I gathered that if f(x) now equals 2x, then ´f(x) = 2, which then is multiplied by g(x) = 3x, to derive 6x.

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ $f'(x) = 2$ not $2x$. $\endgroup$ – user251257 Jul 17 '15 at 10:53
  • $\begingroup$ I know, did I make a mistake? $\endgroup$ – Jim Jam Jul 17 '15 at 10:56
  • $\begingroup$ you wrote $f'(g(x)) = 2\cdot 3x$, but it is just $2$. $\endgroup$ – user251257 Jul 17 '15 at 11:05
  • $\begingroup$ If you want to take the viewpoint that the derivative is a linear transformation, then the chain rule says that $ D (f \circ g)(x) = Df (g (x))\circ Dg (x) $. However, it's unusual to take this viewpoint in single variable calculus. $\endgroup$ – littleO Jul 17 '15 at 11:08
  • $\begingroup$ Oh... that would explain why it would be 6x, as 2*3x = 6x. Though.. if g(x) returns 3x, and f´ = 2, isn't it 2*3x? $\endgroup$ – Jim Jam Jul 17 '15 at 11:09
1
$\begingroup$

$f(g(x))$ = $6x$ where $f(x)$ = $2x$ and $g(x)$ = $3x$ then $f'(g(x))$ = 6. Similarly let $3x$ = $u$ in which case $f(g(x))$ = $2(u)$. Following the chain rule: $d/dx$ $f(g(x))$ = $f´(g(x))$ * $g´(x)$ where $f'(g(x))$ = 2 and $g'(x)$ = $u'$ = 3. Thus 2*3 = 6.

Maybe a problem you're encountering is that above $f(x)$ = $x^2$ and $g(x)$ = $x^3$. So $f'(x) = 2x$ and $g'(x)$ = $3x^2$ But $f(g(x))$ = $x^6$ and $f'(g(x)$ = $6x^5$. Similarly $f'(g(x))$ = $2(x^3)*3*x^2$ = 6x^5.

I hope I understood what you were confused about. Hopefully that helped.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Hello Brianaguirre, thanks very much for your answer. The thing I really don't understand, at least now, is how f´ (g(x)) could equal 2. My understand was that f´ = 2, and is being multiplied by g(x) = 3x. $\endgroup$ – Jim Jam Jul 17 '15 at 11:31
  • $\begingroup$ @user108262 Did you took a look at my answer? I believe I understand your conceptual problem and I tried to address it by adopting a different notation. It helped me when I was struggling with this very problem. $\endgroup$ – Lurco Jul 17 '15 at 11:49
  • $\begingroup$ Ah, I see the confusion. Sorry, I should have used another variable to take the place. You're right about f'(x) = 2 and g(x) = 3x. Take a look the composition of f(x) and g(x) such that f(g(x)) = 2*(3x) = 6x, then I think it's clear that f'(g(x)) = 6. But something I probably forgot to mention was that since we are talking about the derivative of a linear function, for any given input the derivative of f'(g(x)) anywhere on the graph of g(x) = 3x will always be 2, no matter what the input is. Thus f'(g(x))*g'(x) = f'(3x)*3 = 2*3 = 6. Does that make sense? $\endgroup$ – brianaguirre Jul 17 '15 at 12:00
  • $\begingroup$ Yes... I think I see. The thing that did if for me was that you mentioned that d/dx f(g(x)) will always map g(x) accordingly, as well as seeing this visually for myself. So, f(g(x)), where x is 2, is f(g(6)), which is 12, which is 2*6, but in general, TWO x. But man, is that hard to come to terms with. Anyway, thanks very much for your help! You helped give me a little push towards mathematical enlightenment :) $\endgroup$ – Jim Jam Jul 17 '15 at 12:27
1
$\begingroup$

The chain rule works like this: $f'(g(x)) = f'(s)g'(x)$, where the number $s$ is equal to the value of $g$ at point $x$: $s = g(x)$. So $f'(s) = 2$, and subsequently $f'(g(x)) = f'(s) \cdot g'(x) = 2\cdot 3$, as it should without using the chain rule.

A good alternative way to look at the chain rule is through Leibniz notation:

$\frac{df(g(x))}{dx} = \frac{d(f(g(x))}{d g(x)} \cdot \frac{d g(x)}{d x} = \frac{d f(z)}{dz} \cdot \frac{d g(x)}{d x}$

In this notation the chain rule seems trivial. You can actually rigorously prove the chain rule using this approach for $\frac{\Delta f(g(x))}{\Delta x}$ and taking the limit $\Delta x \rightarrow 0$ (so just using the standard definition of the derivative).

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ This is exactly the way I think derivatives should be introduced. $\endgroup$ – user21820 Jul 17 '15 at 11:17

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.