I'm asked to present a continuous function $\alpha \colon S^3 \rightarrow S^2 \vee S^2$ s.t. it is not null homotopic but taken both projections $pr \colon S^2 \vee S^2 \rightarrow S^2$ the composition $pr \circ \alpha$ is null homotopic.

I'm given the hint to use tha fact that $S^2 \times S^2$ is not homotopic equivalent to $S^2 \vee S^2 \vee S^4$ (they cohomology rings are not isomorphic).

Any help or advice is well accepted: thanks in advance.


From the LES in homotopy groups for the pair $(S^2 \times S^2, S^2 \vee S^2)$, we have an exact sequence $$\pi_4(S^2 \vee S^2) \to \pi_4(S^2 \times S^2) \to \pi_4(S^2 \times S^2, S^2 \vee S^2)\to \pi_3(S^2 \vee S^2) \to \pi_3(S^2 \times S^2)$$

Since we have $\pi_k(S^2 \times S^2)\cong \pi_k(S^2 ) \times \pi_k( S^2) \subset \pi_k(S^2 \vee S^2)$, the maps $\pi_k(S^2 \vee S^2) \to \pi_k(S^2 \times S^2)$ are surjective. It follows that $\pi_4(S^2 \times S^2)\to \pi_4(S^2 \times S^2, S^2 \vee S^2)$ is the zero map, giving us a short exact sequence $$0 \to \pi_4(S^2 \times S^2, S^2 \vee S^2)\to \pi_3(S^2 \vee S^2) \to \pi_3(S^2 \times S^2) \to 0.$$ We want an element $\alpha \in \pi_3(S^2 \vee S^2)$ such that its composition with each projection $S^2 \vee S^2 \to S^2$ is nullhomotopic. These projections factor through $S^2 \times S^2$, so $\alpha$ lies in the kernel of the composition $\pi_3(S^2 \vee S^2) \to \pi_3(S^2 \times S^2) \overset{\sim}{\to} \pi_3(S^2) \times \pi_3(S^2)$. Thus it suffices to show that $\pi_4(S^2 \times S^2, S^2 \vee S^2)$ is nontrivial, since any nonzero element in its image in $\pi_3(S^2 \vee S^2)$ will work for us.

Here's where the hint comes in: Recall that $S^2 \times S^2$ has a cell structure with one $0$-cell, two $2$-cells, and one $4$-cell. The 3-skeleton is simply $S^2 \vee S^2$, so the boundary of the 4-cell is mapped into $S^2 \vee S^2$. Since $S^2 \vee S^2 \vee S^4$ is not homotopy equivalent to $S^2 \times S^2$, the 4-cell's attaching map is nontrivial, giving us the desired element of $\pi_3(S^2 \vee S^2)$.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I got the main idea. Unluckily I don't know homotopy theory so I cannot use your proof (but from what I understand it should be correct). I made an ad hoc proof that the attaching map $\alpha$ you propose has the property that $pr \circ \alpha$ is null homotopic: consider the characteristic map $Q \colon D^4 \rightarrow S^2 \times S^2$ associated to $\alpha$, as you said the map $pr$ factorizes through $S^2 \times S^2$ so we have the equality $pr \circ \alpha= \pi \circ Q \circ i$ where $\pi\colon S^2 \times S^2 \rightarrow S^2$ is a projection (continue) $\endgroup$ – N.B. May 28 '15 at 15:44
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ and $i \colon S^3 \hookrightarrow D^4$ the inclusion. But $D^4$ is contractible and it's easy to see that $i$ must be null homotopic leading to the fact that the whole composition $\pi \circ Q \circ i$ is null homotopic as desired. $\endgroup$ – N.B. May 28 '15 at 15:44
  • $\begingroup$ @N.B.: Nice, that's a better argument for showing that $\operatorname{pr}\circ \alpha$ is nullhomotopic. The homotopy-theoretic argument was just me thinking out loud to find a candidate $\alpha$. As you've shown, you can use more elementary techniques to prove that a given $\alpha$ works. $\endgroup$ – Kyle May 28 '15 at 15:56

Consider the attaching map $S^3 \to S^2 \vee S^2$ of the $4$-cell in the standard CW-structure of $S^2 \times S^2$. If this is nullhmotopic, $S^2 \times S^2$ would be homotopic to $S^2 \vee S^2 \vee S^4$ as homotopic attaching map implies homotopy equivalent spaces.

But cup square $\alpha \smile \alpha$ is nontrivial in $H^*(S^2 \times S^2)$ where $\alpha$ is generator of $H^2(S^2)$, whereas it's trivial in $H^*(S^2 \vee S^2 \vee S^4) \cong H^*(S^2) \times H^*(S^2) \times H^*(S^4)$, contradiction.

  • $\begingroup$ @MikeMiller Could you elaborate? $\endgroup$ – Kyle Dec 14 '15 at 14:54
  • $\begingroup$ @Kyle: Ah, that was complete nonsense. Your original comment's suggestion - that we try working with the Hopf map $S^3 \to S^2 \to S^2 \vee S^2$ - does work; the cell structure you get (as in this answer) is $\Bbb{CP}^2 \vee S^2$, which has the wrong cup product structure to be trivial or to be what's in this answer. $\endgroup$ – user98602 Dec 14 '15 at 14:59
  • $\begingroup$ @MikeMiller: Cool. I think we'd need to use $\mathbb{CP}^2 \vee \mathbb{CP}^2$ or something to get both projections to $S^2$ to be nontrivial, using a composition $S^3 \to S^3 \vee S^3 \to S^2 \vee S^2$. $\endgroup$ – Kyle Dec 14 '15 at 15:10

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.