On page $23$ Milnor states:

Let $\varphi$ : $\mathbb{R}^n \rightarrow \mathbb{R}$ be a smooth function which satisfies $$\begin{cases} \varphi(x) > 0, & {\rm for}\,\|x\| < 1 \\ \varphi(x) = 0, &{\rm for}\,\|x\| \geq 1\end{cases}$$ Given any fixed unit vector $c \in \mathbb{S} ^{n-1} $, consider the differential equations $$\frac{dx_i}{dt} = c_{i} \cdot \varphi(x_1,x_2,\dots,x_n); \hspace{10 mm} i = 1, \dots , n.$$ For any $ \hat x \in \mathbb{R}^n$ these equations have a unique solution $x = x(t)$, defined for all real numbers which satisfies the initial condition $$x(0)= \hat x.$$ We will use the notation $x(t) = F_{t}( \hat x)$ for this solution. Then clearly
1) $F_{t}$ is defined for all $t$ and $ \hat x $ and depends smoothly on $t$ and $ \hat x $,
2) $F_{0}( \hat x ) = \hat x $,
3) $F_{s+t}( \hat x ) = F_{s} \circ F_{t}( \hat x )$.

2) is quite clear, however I don't understand why 1) and 3) are valid. Could anybody explain that?

Moreover on page $24$ Milnor states that

clearly, with suitable choice of $c$ and $t$, the diffeomorphism $F_{t}$ will carry the origin to any desired point in the open unit ball.

Is that really 'clear'? Wouldn't it be necessary to show that $x(t) \rightarrow c$ when $t \rightarrow \infty $? If it is, how?

Thanks in advance.

Source: http://www.maths.ed.ac.uk/~aar/papers/milnortop.pdf

  • $\begingroup$ Because $\phi$ has compact support and is smooth, $\phi'$ is bounded, hence uniformly Lipschitz. This gives existence and uniqueness. The system is time invariant, so time shifted solutions are also solutions. The function $F$ gives the solution at time $t$ starting from $x$. I need to think if there is a quick answer to smoothness with respect to initial condition. $\endgroup$ – copper.hat May 20 '15 at 0:55

To answer your "Moreover" part: The path $x(t)$ starts at $0$ and travels in a straight line in the direction $c$. The limit of $x(t)$ as $t \to \infty$ must exist, because $x(t)$ is traveling in one direction on the straight line given by the vector $c$. Let's call the limit $x_\infty$. Now, you can imagine intuitively that the path must slow down as $t \to \infty$. By continuity of $\phi$ this should mean that $\phi$ is $0$ at $x_\infty$. This means that $x_\infty$ must be at the boundary of the circle.

More rigorously, Suppose that $|x_\infty| < 1$. There must be a sequence of times $t_n$ ($t_n \to \infty$ as $n \to \infty$) such that $$\lim_{n \to \infty} |x'(t_n)| = 0.$$ (See edit 2 below.) Since (by the differential equation) $|x'(t_n)| = |\phi(x(t_n))||c|$ we have $$0 = \lim_{n \to \infty} |x'(t_n)| = \lim_{n \to \infty}|\phi(x(t_n))||c| = \phi(x_\infty)|c|$$ and therefore $\phi(x_\infty) = 0$, so $x_\infty$ is on the boundary of the circle.

From this picture, you see that $x(t)$ sweeps out the whole line segment $$\{rc : 0 < r < \frac{1}{|c|} \}$$

Edit: let me answer your first part. (1) The existence, uniqueness, and smoothness of the solution is a fact you may learn in an ODE course. There are notes here: math.ucsb.edu/~sideris/Math243-F09/notes-09-10.pdf In particular, you want:

--Corollary 5.1.1 (Smooth dependence on initial conditions)

--Theorem 2.3.1 (Existence and Uniqueness)

It is a bit unfair to say 'clearly'.

(3) The third property essentially follows from uniqueness. In words, the property says that "flowing for time $s+t$ is the same as flowing for time $t$, then flowing for time $s$." To see this let $\hat x$ and $t$ be given. Notice that $$y(s) = F_{s+t}(\hat x)$$ and $$z(s) = F_s \circ F_t(\hat x)$$ both satisfy the same equation and initial conditions: $$\frac{dy(s)}{ds} = \phi(y(s))c \qquad y(0) = F_t(\hat x)$$ $$\frac{dz(s)}{ds} = \phi(z(s))c \qquad z(0) = F_t(\hat x)$$ so by uniqueness they must be the same.

Edit 2: Clarification of the speed going to 0. Suppose there is no such sequence of times. This would mean that $|x'(t)|$ stays large after some point in time. Specifically, for some time $T$ and small $\delta$, for all $t > T$, we have $|x'(t)| > \delta$. Thus the total distance traveled in the path $x(t)$: $$\int_0^\infty |x'(t)|dt$$ is infinite. That contradicts the fact that $x(t)$ starts at the origin, travels in the direction given by $c$, and does not go farther than distance 1 from the origin.

Edit 3: Clarification clarification. Let's assume that $|c| = 1$, otherwise you just have to normalize some things.

Thinking about the path of the origin, we're looking at the ODE $$\frac{dx(t)}{dt} = \varphi(x(t))c, \qquad x(0) = 0.$$ Since $x(t)$ is always a multiple of $c$ this is equivalent to the one dimensional ODE $$\frac{dr(t)}{dt} = \psi(r(t)), \qquad r(0) = 0$$ where $$x(t) = r(t)c, \qquad \psi(r) = \varphi(rc).$$ Since $\psi(r)\geq 0$, the solution $r(t)$ is increasing in time. Furthermore $r(t)$ is bounded by $1$, because $\psi(r) = 0$ for $r\geq 1$. Now, $$r(T) = \int_0^T r'(t) dt$$ Since the left hand side is bounded as $T \to \infty$, and since the integrand is nonnegative, we have $$\int_0^\infty r'(t) dt < \infty$$ which tells us $r'(t)$ must go to 0 as $t \to \infty$. So, $$0 = \lim_{t \to \infty}r'(t) = \lim_{t \to \infty}\psi(r(t)) = \psi(\lim_{t \to \infty}r(t))$$ which tells us $\lim_{t \to \infty}r(t)=1$.

  • $\begingroup$ Thank you, great explanations. Could you clarify why $\lim_{n \to \infty} |x'(t_n)| = 0$ in the first part? $\endgroup$ – Dave2k13 May 21 '15 at 10:36
  • $\begingroup$ I put an edit. The answer is kind of based on intuition, but you can probably turn it into a calculation involving integrals. The key thing for that would be the fact that $\left< x(t), c \right> =|c|^2 \int_0^t \phi(x(s)) ds $ $\endgroup$ – Tim Carson May 21 '15 at 20:47
  • $\begingroup$ I've thought about it, but I can't come up with anything useful. Could you give it a try to write a complete formal solution for the "moreover" part? $\endgroup$ – Dave2k13 May 26 '15 at 18:33
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I added it again. Hopefully putting it as a 1d ode makes it easier. $\endgroup$ – Tim Carson May 27 '15 at 19:10

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.