If $A$ is a commutative ring with unity, then a fact proved in most commutative algebra textbooks is:

$$\dim A + 1\leq\dim A[X] \leq 2\dim A + 1$$

Idea of proof: each prime of $A$ in a chain can arise from at most two prime ideals of $A[X]$.

The left equality holds when $A$ is a noetherian ring, but this paper of Seidenberg shows that, for rings of fixed dimension, every value in the interval is achievable.

There seems to be a shortage of elementary references on these counterexamples, however, so I thought it might be good to collect some specific examples of commutative rings $A$ with $\dim A[X] > \dim A$, or knowledge about simple cases.

In particular, it would be good to have some examples of rings $A$ with $\dim A = 1$ and $\dim A[X]=3$.

Here is an example I just worked out, inspired by Seidenberg's paper.

Let $k$ be a field, with $t$ transcendental over $k$, and let $A = \{f\in k(t)[[Y]] \mid f(0) \in k\}$. Then $A$ has unique nonzero prime ideal $P = \{f\in k(t)[[Y]] \mid f(0) = 0\}$, with $A/P \cong k$, so $\dim A = 1$.

To see that $\dim A[X]=3$, it is enough to exhibit a prime ideal lying between $(0)$ and $P[X]$. Consider the map $A[X] \to k(t)[[Y]]$ given by $p(X) \mapsto p(t)$. The image is an integral domain, so the kernel $K$ is prime. But $(YX-tY)\in K$, while $Y\notin K$, so $(0)\subsetneq K \subsetneq P[X]$.


Here is a classification of all integral domains $A$ with $\dim A=1$, $\dim A[X]=3$:

First, consider the map $\operatorname{Spec} A[X]\to\operatorname{Spec} A$ given by $\mathfrak{p}\to\mathfrak{p}\cap A$. The fiber over $P$ is isomorphic to $\operatorname{Spec} A_P / PA_P\otimes_A A[X] \cong (A_P / PA_P)[X]$, which is one-dimensional. It follows that a chain of three distinct primes in $A[X]$ cannot have the same intersection with $A$.

Suppose that there is a chain of four prime ideals in $A[X]$. By the previous paragraph, intersecting with $A$ must give us $(0)\subset (0) \subset P \subset P$ for some maximal $P\subset A$. It follows that the first three elements of the chain are $(0) \subsetneq \mathfrak{q} \subsetneq P[X]$, with $\mathfrak{q}\cap A = (0)$. The existence of such a $\mathfrak{q}$ is therefore equivalent to $\dim A[X] = 3$.

Then the map $A[X]\to K(A[X]/\mathfrak{q})$ restricts to an injection $A\to K(A[X]/\mathfrak{q})$, which induces an injection $K(A)\to K(A[X]/\mathfrak{q})$. So $\mathfrak{q}$ is the kernel of a map from $A[X]$ to a field extension of $K(A)$. Let $t$ be the image of $X$ under this map.

Since $\mathfrak{q}\neq (0)$, $t$ is algebraic over $K(A)$. Since $\mathfrak{q}\subset P[X]$, $t$ is transcendental over $K(A/P)$.

So all examples arise from a dimension $1$ integral domain $A$ with a maximal ideal $P$, such that there is some $t\in \overline{K(A)}$ that is transcendental over $K(A/P)$—i.e. every integral equation satisfied by $t$ has coefficients in $P$.

(Note: In the original example, $t$ satisfies the polynomial $p(T) = YT - tY$, so this is probably close to the simplest example of an element of $K(A)$ transcendental over $K(A/P)$.)

Conversely, such a $t$ gives rise to our desired prime ideal $\mathfrak{q}$.

Can the condition $t\in \overline{K(A)}$ be simplified to $t\in K(A)$? If so, the condition is much simpler: we must have some $t\in K(A)$ that can only be written as a fraction with both numerator and denominator in $P$.

  • $\begingroup$ What is $K(-)$? Fraction field? Also, you say that "WLOG it is a domain", which seems to be reducing $A$ modulo minimal prime (is that right?). How do you reconstruct back all the possibly non-domain $A$'s? I see it can be done mechanically, but i there some "natural formulation"? $\endgroup$ – Pavel Čoupek May 5 '15 at 5:59
  • $\begingroup$ @PavelČoupek It's the fraction field. And I think that the most natural formulation is "$A$ has a minimal prime $P$ such that $A/P$ has the property stated." I kind of consider the question of finding all such $A$ to be a separate one, and in general I'm not sure whether this is tractable for non-noetherian rings. $\endgroup$ – Slade May 5 '15 at 16:55

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.