Suppose we have a manifold $M$ that is the product of $k$ copies of real projective space, say $$ M = \prod_{i=1}^k \mathbb{R} P^{n_i}.$$ Then $H^*(M; \mathbb{Z}/2) = \mathbb{Z}/2 [ \alpha_1, \dots, \alpha_k] / (\alpha_1^{n_1 + 1}, \dots, \alpha_k^{n_k + 1})$. Let $\sigma \in H^1(M) = \alpha_1 + \dots + \alpha_k$. Now suppose we have some sub-manifold $N \subseteq M$ with inclusion $i : N \to M$. Let $\nu$ denote the normal bundle of $N$ in $M$. I came across a statement that for a specific sub-manifold $N$ constructed in a certain way, $$ w(\nu) = i^*(1 + \sigma) $$ where $w(\nu)$ is the total Stiefel-Whitney class of $\nu$. Is this true for an arbitrary sub-manifold $N$? If so, how can you see this?

  • $\begingroup$ This should be definitely true for $1$-submanifolds $N$, i.e. embeddings of the circle. This is related to the fact, that $\mathbb RP^1$ is a $K(\mathbb Z_2,1)$. $\endgroup$ – Daniel Valenzuela Apr 23 '15 at 5:52

There is of course an obvious counter-example when $N=M$ and $i$ is the identity. In this case, $w(\nu)=1$ (since $\nu$ has rank $0$), but $i^*(1 + \sigma) = 1 + \sigma$.

In the case you are considering, they are likely using the fact that the pullback of the tangent bundle of $M$ splits as $TN \oplus \nu = i^* TM$. Hence, the Whitney product formula and naturality imply that $w(TN)\cdot w(\nu) = i^* w(TM)$. The total Stiefel-Whitney class of $\mathbb{R}P^n$ is given by $(1 + \alpha)^{n+1} \in H^*(\mathbb{R}P^n, \mathbb{Z}_2) = \mathbb{Z}_2[\alpha] / (\alpha^{n+1})$. It follows from the Whitney product formula that $w(M) = \prod_{i=1}^k (1+\alpha_i)^{n_i+1}$. One can then compute $w(\nu)$ from $w(TN)$ and the pullback of the $\alpha_i$.

For a less trivial counter-example than the one above, consider the usual embedding of $N=\mathbb{R}P^{n}$ into $M=\mathbb{R}P^{n+k}$. The generator $\alpha$ of $H^1(\mathbb{R}P^{n+k}, \mathbb{Z}_2)$ pulls back to the generator $\tilde{\alpha}$ of $H^1(\mathbb{R}P^{n}, \mathbb{Z}_2)$. Therefore, $w(TN)\cdot w(\nu) = i^* w(TM)$ becomes $(1+\tilde{\alpha})^{n+1} \cdot w(\nu) = (1+\tilde{\alpha})^{n+k+1}$, and so $w(\nu) = (1+\tilde{\alpha})^k$ which in general does not equal $i^*(1+\sigma) = 1+ \tilde{\alpha}$ in $H^*(\mathbb{R}P^n, \mathbb{Z}_2)$. In fact, even if $n=1$ they can be made non-equal by taking $k$ even. This example easily generalizes to products of projective spaces.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.