5
$\begingroup$

I don't understand some of the terminology in this question. I googled reciprocal vectors and got an article on reciprocal lattices, but I'm not sure if that is what they are talking about in this question. Also, when they say that ${\bf A}$, ${\bf B}$, and ${\bf C}$ are defined by ... plus cyclic permutations, again I looked at the wikipedia article on the subject, but I still do not understand the concept. Does anyone have a link for a clear explanation?

The vectors ${\bf a}$, ${\bf b}$, and ${\bf c}$ are non-coplanar, and form a non-orthogonal vector base. The vectors ${\bf A}$, ${\bf B}$, and ${\bf C}$, defined by

$$ {\bf A} = \frac{{\bf b}\times {\bf c}}{{\bf a}\cdot{\bf b}\times {\bf c}}, $$

plus cyclic permutations, are said to be reciprocal vectors. Show that

$$ {\bf a} = \frac{{\bf B}\times {\bf C}}{{\bf A}\cdot{\bf B}\times {\bf C}}, $$

plus cyclic permutations.

thanks

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Reciprocal vector: the vector which has the same direction as that of vector $A$ but has magnitude reciprocal to that of vector $A$, is called the reciprocal of vector $A$ and is denoted as vector $A^{-1}$ $\endgroup$ – shadab Ali Feb 12 at 13:28
3
$\begingroup$

Cyclic means a cyclic permutation of the operands: $$ {\bf A} \to {\bf B}, {\bf B} \to {\bf C}, {\bf C} \to {\bf A} \quad a \to b, b \to c, c \to a $$ This gives $$ {\bf A} = \frac{{\bf b}\times {\bf c}}{{\bf a}\cdot({\bf b}\times {\bf c})} \quad {\bf B} = \frac{{\bf c}\times {\bf a}}{{\bf b}\cdot({\bf c}\times {\bf a})} \quad {\bf C} = \frac{{\bf a}\times {\bf b}}{{\bf c}\cdot({\bf a}\times {\bf b})} $$ and $$ {\bf a} = \frac{{\bf B}\times {\bf C}}{{\bf A}\cdot({\bf B}\times {\bf C})} \quad {\bf b} = \frac{{\bf C}\times {\bf A}}{{\bf B}\cdot({\bf C}\times {\bf A})} \quad {\bf c} = \frac{{\bf A}\times {\bf B}}{{\bf C}\cdot({\bf A}\times {\bf B})} $$

From Reciprocal Lattice

[..] the "crystallographer's" definition, comes from defining the reciprocal lattice to be $e^{2 \pi i\mathbf{K}\cdot\mathbf{R}}=1$ which changes the definitions of the reciprocal lattice vectors to be

$ \mathbf{b_{1}}=\frac{\mathbf{a_{2}} \times \mathbf{a_{3}}}{\mathbf{a_{1}} \cdot (\mathbf{a_{2}} \times \mathbf{a_{3}})}$ and so on for the other vectors. The crystallographer's definition has the advantage that the definition of $\mathbf{b_{1}}$ is just the reciprocal magnitude of $\mathbf{a_{1}}$ in the direction of $\mathbf{a_{2}} \times \mathbf{a_{3}}$, dropping the factor of $2 \pi$.

Checking the magnitude:

$$ \lVert{\bf A}\rVert = \frac{\lVert {\bf b} \times{\bf c}\rVert}{\lVert{\bf a}\rVert\lVert{\bf b}\times {\bf c}\rVert\cos\angle({\bf a}, {\bf b} \times{\bf c})} = \frac{1}{\lVert{\bf a}\rVert ({\bf e_a} \cdot {\bf e}_{{\bf b} \times{\bf c}})} $$

Solving the question:

Using the "bac-cab" rule ${\bf a}\times({\bf b}\times{\bf c}) = {\bf b}({\bf a}\cdot {\bf c}) - {\bf c}({\bf a}\cdot {\bf b})$ we go for the nominator of ${\bf B}\times{\bf C}$: $$ ({\bf c}\times {\bf a})\times({\bf a}\times{\bf b}) = {\bf a}(({\bf c}\times{\bf a})\cdot{\bf b})-{\bf b}(({\bf c}\times{\bf a})\cdot{\bf a})= {\bf a}(({\bf c}\times{\bf a})\cdot{\bf b}) $$ because ${\bf c}\times{\bf a} \perp {\bf a}$. This gives $$ {\bf B}\times{\bf C} = \frac{{\bf a}(({\bf c}\times{\bf a})\cdot{\bf b})}{({\bf b}\cdot({\bf c}\times {\bf a}))({\bf c}\cdot({\bf a}\times {\bf b}))} = \frac{{\bf a}}{{\bf c}\cdot({\bf a}\times {\bf b})} \\ {\bf A}\cdot({\bf B}\times{\bf C}) = \frac{{\bf b}\times {\bf c}}{{\bf a}\cdot({\bf b}\times {\bf c})} \cdot \frac{{\bf a}}{{\bf c}\cdot({\bf a}\times {\bf b})} = \frac{1}{{\bf c}\cdot({\bf a}\times {\bf b})} $$ Dividing those gives the desired result $$ \frac{{\bf B}\times{\bf C}}{{\bf A}\cdot({\bf B}\times{\bf C})} = \frac{{\bf c}\cdot({\bf a}\times {\bf b})\,{\bf a}}{{\bf c}\cdot({\bf a}\times {\bf b})} = {\bf a} $$

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ hey thanks, do you mean to say that we can use the magnitude to show the proof? I'm a little stumped by this one, even now that I understand the terminology. do you have any suggestions on how to approach the solution? $\endgroup$ – sean read Apr 8 '15 at 10:42
  • $\begingroup$ The last bit above was to understand the last sentence of the cited text. Which proof and solution do you mean? $\endgroup$ – mvw Apr 8 '15 at 11:26
  • $\begingroup$ that the question is asking for, to show from $$ {\bf A} = \frac{{\bf b}\times {\bf c}}{{\bf a}\cdot{\bf b}\times {\bf c}} $$ that $$ {\bf a} = \frac{{\bf B}\times {\bf C}}{{\bf A}\cdot{\bf B}\times {\bf C}} $$ $\endgroup$ – sean read Apr 8 '15 at 11:47
  • $\begingroup$ I added that bit. $\endgroup$ – mvw Apr 8 '15 at 13:19
3
$\begingroup$

I think they intended to write $A\cdot (B\times C)$, which is a scalar; the vectors are non-coplanar, hence this scalar is nonzero and hence we can safely divide by this scalar.

This wiki article would be a good start.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ oh I see, so then permutations would be, for example $$ {\bf B} = \frac{{\bf c}\times {\bf a}}{{\bf b}\cdot{\bf c}\times {\bf a}}, $$ but I'm still not sure what they mean by reciprocal vectors... $\endgroup$ – sean read Apr 7 '15 at 12:06
  • $\begingroup$ @seanread It's just a name. Looking at ${\bf A} = \frac{{\bf b}\times {\bf c}}{{\bf a}\cdot{\bf b}\times {\bf c}},$, if you "cancel" $\bf b\times \bf c$, then you are left with $\bf A=\frac{1}{\bf a}$, the "reciprocal" of $\bf a$. Of course, you can't legitimately carry out this cancellation but it does help to explain the name. $\endgroup$ – Kim Jong Un Apr 7 '15 at 12:11

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.