# How to find all proper colorings (four coloring) of a graph with a brute force algorithm

I'd like to implement a brute force algorithm to search ALL the different colorings of a map.

In terms of graph theory I'd like to find all four colorings of the vertices of a planar graph (the dual representing the map).

I need help or hints to put me on the right direction.

I'm interested in maps in which each face is an opaque rectangle layered on all previous rectangles, overlapping partially. Each consecutive rectangle starts at a consecutive y coordinate. The next picture should better clarify what I mean. The faces are numbered from 1 to n

• face 1 is the face on the bottom of the pile
• face (n-1) is the face at the top
• face n is the infinite face surrounding all others

For the meaning of different colorings you can refer to this question:

I was thinking to pre-set the colors of faces and use a classical brute force algorithm to get four coloring of the map. I already implemented the brute

force algorithm to find the proper coloring of a map and I can also force the color of faces to find particolar colorings.

The problem is that I'm not coming up with an algorithm to do it automatically and to be sure to find ALL colorings.

To see what I have so far, you can watch this video on youtube:

What I know is that:

• Since the colors of three neighboor faces can be arbitrary, face number n, face number 1 and the face touching both (face n and face 1), can have these fixed colors: blue, red, green

Manually I found these colorings: This is a cross site post on cstheory.

You can generate all 4 (or other number) colorings using Sage, an open source computer math system. You can use it free online without having to install it at http://www.sagenb.org/

If you can input your graph in Sage to the symbol G, then the following code will print all the graph G with all the different colorings

for C in sage.graphs.graph_coloring.all_graph_colorings(G, 4):
G.plot(vertex_colors = C)

• web site is down Mar 17, 2017 at 17:44

This C code below generates all $4$-colourings of a graph with <=31 vertices. It's a basic depth-first search, backtracking algorithm.

• It's not designed to be overly efficient, but some obvious improvements have been made. I believe there would be vastly better implementations out there (this problem screams SSE). (But my impression is that you're after a simple but effective solution.)
• It's restricted to graphs with at most 31 vertices since I use bitwise operations. On a 64-bit machine this could be increased. Otherwise, a more complicated version would be required (e.g. dividing the adjacency matrix into 4 smaller adjacency matrices).
• We can assume the vertex $0$ is coloured $0$ (this saves a run-time factor of $4$). [If you want to include the other colourings, add $+d$ too all colours, as $d$ runs over $0,1,2,3$.]
• It generates a random graph to work on initially. This will need to be edited to allow your own input.

Keep in mind that, depending on the density of your input graph, there might be gazillions of $4$-colourings, and, in such a case, no program would be able to run to completion, regardless of how good your algorithm is and how good your coding skills are. Merely iterating through all possible $4$-colourings, even with the aid of an oracle, would be too slow.

#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdlib.h>
#include <time.h>

#define MAX_NR_VERTICES 31
#define MAX_NR_EDGES MAX_NR_VERTICES*(MAX_NR_VERTICES-1)/2
#define VERBOSE 0

const int n=31;

/* the u-th bit of adjacency[v] is 1 whenever {u,v} is an edge in the graph */

/* colour[v] is the colour of vertex v */
int colour[MAX_NR_VERTICES];

/* a counter for the number of colourings */
int nr_colourings;

void generate_4_colourings_backtracking_algorithm(int v) {
/* attempts to use colour c for vertex v */
for(int c=0;c<4;c++) {
for(int u=0;u<v;u++) {
/* checks if there is a vertex u adjacent to v coloured c */
/* only the vertices before v have been coloured thusfar */
if((adjacency[v] & 1 << u) && colour[u]==c) { goto dont_use_this_colour; }
}

/* trying colour c for vertex v */
colour[v]=c;

if(v==n-1) {
/* found a proper colouring */
nr_colourings++;
/* if VERBOSE is set to 1, this will print the colouring to the screen */
if(VERBOSE) { printf("colouring %d: ",nr_colourings); for(int u=0;u<n;u++) { printf("%d ",colour[u]); } printf("\n"); }
}
else {
/* normal backtracking step */
generate_4_colourings_backtracking_algorithm(v+1);
}

dont_use_this_colour: ;
}
}

int main() {
if(n>MAX_NR_VERTICES) { return 0; }

/* generates a random list of edges for the graph */
srand(time(NULL));
int u;
for(int v=0;v<n;v++) {
int nr_edges=3;
for(int i=0;i<nr_edges;i++) {
do { u=rand()%n; } while (u==v);
}
}
printf("Adjacency matrix:\n"); for(int v=0;v<n;v++) { for(int u=0;u<n;u++) { printf("%d",(adjacency[v] >> u) & 1); } printf("\n"); } printf("\n");
/* finished generating random graph */

/* by symmetry, we can assume vertex 0 is coloured 0 */
colour=0;
generate_4_colourings_backtracking_algorithm(1);

printf("Found %d canonical 4-colourings; %d total 4-colourings\n",nr_colourings,4*nr_colourings);

return 1;
}

• Doug, can you explain what the nr_edges =3 is for? I can only see the i-loop randomly selecting up to 3 different bits (selected by the three random u values pulled). Jul 27, 2016 at 15:55

You can reduce any problem of vertex coloring to a problem of finding the Grobner basis for some ideal in $k[x_1,..,x_n]$. And this last problem can be solved with Buchberger's Algorithm. You can try that for the dual of your graph, probably not the best approach.

Google returned many pages which contain this basic idea, here is one example:

Graph coloring and Grobner bases

• Wow, how fast! I'll take a look into it. For my level it seems too difficult to understand and implement, but i'll try to see what I can do. I was hoping for a simpler approach to the problem! Thanks for the info Mar 15, 2012 at 17:05
• Groebner basis are rarely computed by Buchberger's algorithm. Typically faster algorithms F4 and F5 (IIRC) of Faugère are used. IIRC, Singular software has the fastest Groebner basis implementation.
– user2468
Mar 15, 2012 at 18:11

Input: A planar graph $G(V,E)$.

Output: A printed list of every valid 4 coloring of $G$.

• For all functions $f : V \to \{1,2,3,4\}$
• If $f(V)$ is a valid coloring of $G$
• Print $f(V)$
• How do I find all functions f:V→{1,2,3,4}? All possible functions, without filtering them first (for not valid coloring), seem to be a very high number of solutions. Mar 15, 2012 at 17:21
• There are $4^{|V|}$ such functions. This should not matter because you said that you are interested in a brute force algorithm. There is a 1-to-1 correspondence bettwen $|V|$-tuples in $\{1,2,3,4\}^{|V|}$ and functions $f : V \to \{1,2,3,4\}$. For the direction that you care about, from a $|V|$-tuple $u = (u_1, u_2, \ldots, u_{|V|}) \in \{1,2,3,4\}$, define $f_u(i) = u_i$. Even more concretely. Instead of using $\{1,2,3,4\}$, use $\{0,1,2,3\}$. Then a $|V|$-tuple in $\{0,1,2,3\}^{|V|}$ is the same as a number between 0 and 333...3 (where there are $|V|$ 3's) in base 4. Mar 15, 2012 at 17:36
• @Mario Does this make sense? Mar 16, 2012 at 16:33
• Yes it does, but that is exactly why I'm looking for an algorithm. I'm working with graphs that have 30-50 vertices and that makes impossible to find all possible colorings and then filter them out. I'l like to write something similar to the function colorIt() inside this java code: - maps-coloring.git.sourceforge.net/git/… implementing for example a new method called findAllColorings() Mar 16, 2012 at 18:47
• @Mario This is an algorithm, a brute force algorithm like you requested. If you want something efficient (in the output size), then this is probably a good question to ask on TCS.SE. Mar 17, 2012 at 3:34