8
$\begingroup$

Find conditions on positive integers $a, b, c$ so that $\sqrt{a}+\sqrt{b}+\sqrt{c}$ is irrational.

My solution: if $ab$ is not the square of an integer, then the expression is irrational. I find it interesting that $c$ does not come into this at all.

My solution is modeled (i.e., copied with modifications) from dexter04's solution to Prove that $\sqrt{3}+ \sqrt{5}+ \sqrt{7}$ is irrational .

Suppose $\sqrt{a}+\sqrt{b}+\sqrt{c} = r$ where $r$ is rational. Then, $(\sqrt{a}+\sqrt{b})^2 = (r-\sqrt{c})^2 \implies a+b+2\sqrt{ab} = c+r^2-2r\sqrt{c}$.

So, $a+b-c-r^2+2\sqrt{ab} =-2r\sqrt{c}$. Let $a+b-c-r^2 = k$, which will be a rational number. So, $(k+2\sqrt{ab})^2 = k^2+ 4ab+4k\sqrt{ab} = 4cr^2$ or $4k\sqrt{ab} = 4cr^2-k^2- 4ab$.

If $ab$ is not a square of an integer, then the LHS is irrational while the RHS is rational. Hence, we have a contradiction.

$\endgroup$
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ Whats the question? $\endgroup$ – Jonny Mar 23 '15 at 20:07
  • $\begingroup$ That's because it's not a complete characterization: $a=b=1$, $c=2$ $\endgroup$ – WimC Mar 23 '15 at 20:07
  • $\begingroup$ @Jonny I think he's asking if his answer is correct. $\endgroup$ – John Mar 23 '15 at 20:09
  • $\begingroup$ Sufficient conditions here : math.stackexchange.com/questions/136556 $\endgroup$ – Watson Dec 25 '16 at 14:18
0
$\begingroup$

For $\sqrt{a}+\sqrt{b}+\sqrt{c}$ to be rational, $ab$ being a perfect square is only a necessary condition, but it is not sufficient (your proof is correct, only the conclusion that it is sufficient is wrong). The sufficient and necessary condition is $a,b,c$ are all perfect squares (easy to see that it is sufficient and I'm going to prove it is necessary).

Symmetry lets us conclude $ab=A^2,bc=B^2,ca=C^2$.

Let $(a,b)=d$. Then $a=da_1, b=db_1$ and since $d^2a_1b_1=A^2$, we have $a=da_2^2, b=db_2^2$.

$bc=B^2\implies db_2^2c=B^2\implies dc=b_3^2\tag{1}$

Let $(c,d)=D$. Then $c=Dc', d=Dd'$. $(1)\implies c=Dc_1^2, d=Dd_1^2$.

So $(a,b,c)=(D(d_1a_2)^2,D(d_1b_2)^2,Dc_1^2)$

$$\sqrt{a}+\sqrt{b}+\sqrt{c}=\sqrt{D}(|d_1a_2|+|d_1b_2|+|c_1|)\in\mathbb Q\iff \sqrt{D}\in\mathbb Q$$$$\iff \sqrt{D}\in\mathbb Z\iff D=D'^2$$

I used the fact that $\sqrt{a},a\in\mathbb Z$ is either an integer or irrational. If it is rational but not an integer, then $\sqrt{a}=\frac{a'}{b'}, a'\nmid b'\implies a=\frac{a'^2}{b'^2}$.
Contradiction, since LHS is an integer and RHS is not ($a'\nmid b'\iff a'^2\nmid b'^2$).

$(a,b,c)=((D'd_1a_2)^2,(D'd_1b_2)^2,(D'c_1)^2)\ \ \ \square$

$\endgroup$
3
$\begingroup$

The answer is that if any of $a, b, c$ is not a square of an integer, then $\sqrt{a} +\sqrt{b} +\sqrt{c}$ must be irrational.

The proof of the general case is not very easy. The paper Square roots have no unexpected linear relationships by Qiaochu Yuan at https://qchu.wordpress.com/2009/07/02/square-roots-have-no-unexpected-linear-relationships/ explains this non-trivial theorem.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.