This question is from an article I read online, titled: "Why I Will Never Have a Girlfriend" by Tristan Miller.

The author shows his work, step-by-step throughout most of the article, except during the conclusion, when he makes the following statement:

  • "At first glance, a datable population of 18,726 may not seem like such a low number, but consider this: assuming I were to go on a blind date with a new girl about my age every week, I would have to date for 3,493 weeks before I found 1 of the 18,726."

He does not explain how he determined 3,493 is the number required to find 1 of the 18,726. I would really like to know. It seems similar to the Birthday Paradox, but I'm not certain?

Thank you in advance for any help / clue. I would especially appreciate anyone who explained, step-by-step how to figure this out, mathematically.

P.S. Apologies; I am not even certain exactly what type of math problem this even is, or what to call it.

  • You forgot to mention that he is considering a sample space of $65\,399\,083$ girls aged between $18$ and $25$. – Christian Blatter Mar 4 '15 at 9:17
  • My apologies. This problem honestly threw me through a loop; I can't believe I missed that! My mind was totally focused on this being some kind of combination/permutation problem that I was totally blind to the obvious solution. I thought that the author's conclusion section was a self-contained problem, and not related to the numerous previous statements he made earlier in the paper, thus I didn't realize the relevance. – questionthis Mar 4 '15 at 12:25

He considers

  • the #girls his age: 65399083,
  • and the #girls that are dateable (a good match for him) 18726.

If he dates blindly (uniformly at random from all girls his age) once every week, the probability he will meet a dateable girl on any given week is $$ p = \frac{18726}{65399083}. $$ The inverse $1/p$ is the expected time in weeks (mean of geometric distribution) till he meets a girl from the dateable set and is the number you want: $$ \frac{1}{p} = \frac{65399083}{18726} = 3492.42139. $$

  • Oh my god, lol. Thank you! I can't believe I missed that; I thought I was going crazy! I kept thinking there was some kind of secret mathematical principle I was missing! – questionthis Mar 4 '15 at 8:43
  • How do I +1 you? Lol – questionthis Mar 4 '15 at 8:43

Your Answer

 

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.