6
$\begingroup$

What is the maximum area two non intersecting circles can cover if they are contained in a unit square?

I think that they cover the most area when in the following position: enter image description here

However I haven't been able to prove this is the best possible way. In this configuration the large circle has radius $\frac{1}{2}$ and the small circle has radius $\frac{\sqrt2 -1}{2\sqrt{2}+2}$.

So the sum of the areas is approximately $0.808$

I have an Idea as to how to prove it is maximum. Prove the two vertices must be on the diagonal and then do some algebraic inequalities. But I'd like to see a clean-cut proof, because I have come across this type of problem before and I often write sloppy solutions for them.

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

One approach (broadly sketched) would be as follows.

First show that if a maximal area is covered, every side of the square must be touched be a circle. Prove this by contradiction: Assume there is a side not touched by a circle, let the circle center $C_1$ of radius $r_1$ be closer to that side than the circle center $C_2$, and construct a circle whose radius is larger than $r_1$ and that does not overlap either the circle at $C_2$ or any side of the square. (One construction is, take the line tangent to both circles where they touch; that line plus sides and/or partial sides of the square form a triangle, quadrilateral, or pentagon enclosing $C_1$; inscribe a circle in that polygon. Show in each case that the circle inscribed in the polygon has a radius greater than $r_1$.)

That's the hard part.

Next show that if a circle touches more than two sides, it touches all four (and you end up with the diagram you showed).

Then assume there is a maximal-area arrangement in which neither circle touches more than two sides. Since all four sides must touch a circle, one pair of sides must touch one circle and the remaining pair of sides must touch the other. Show that the sides in each pair cannot be opposite sides, so they must be adjacent sides.

Show that if a circle touches two adjacent sides, its center lies on the diagonal between those two sides. Moreover, the diagonal between one pair of adjacent sides is the same as the diagonal between the other two sides. Hence the centers of the two circles lie on the same diagonal.

You can then easily show by contradiction that the circles must touch, so the entire configuration can be determined by the radius of one circle.

From there you can use algebra or calculus to find the radius that gives the maximum combined area of the circles.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.