I wonder whether there exists a link between the number of generators and relations of a presentation for a given group $G$ and the ranks of its (co)homology groups $H_1(G,\mathbb{Z})$ and $H_2(G, \mathbb{Z})$. For example, if $\langle X \mid R \rangle$ is a presentation of a group $G$ such that $R$ has as less relations as possible provided that $|X|= \mathrm{rank}(G)$, can we say that $\mathrm{rank}~H_2(G,\mathbb{Z}) = |R|$? It seems to be true at least for some groups.

I am not really familiar with (co)homology of groups, so I don't know what would be a pertinent formulation. Instead, I conclude with a pretty vague question:

Is it possible to link minimal presentations and (co)homology groups?


Let$G=\langle X \mid R \rangle$, so $G=F/N$, with $F$ free on $X$ and $N=\langle R^F \rangle$.

Then the Schur Multiplier $M(G) = H_2(G,{\mathbb Z})$ of $G$ is isomorphic to $N \cap [F,F]/[F,N]$.

Note that $N/(N \cap [F,F]) \cong N[F,F]/[F,F]$ is free abelian of rank equal to $|X| - r_1$, where $r_1$ ia the torsion-free rank of $F/N[F,F] \cong G/[G,G] \cong H_1(G,{\mathbb Z})$. So, since $N/[F,N]$ can be generated by the images of the elements of $R$, $m(G)$ can be generated by at most $|R|-|X| + r_1$ elements. The presentation is called efficient if this is the minimal number of generators of $M(G)$.

There has been a lot of work done on search for efficient presentations of finite groups (where $r_1=0$). There are known examples that do not have efficient presentations, but I think it is still an open problem whether every finite $p$-group has one. So an efficient presentation of a group with $M(G)=0$ would be a balanced presentation with $|X|=|R|$. For example

$Q_8 = \langle x,y \mid x^2=y^2,y^{-1}xy=y^{-1} \rangle$.

Note also that $|X|-|R|$ is called the deficiency of the presentation.


Brown mentions the same relation in the fifth exercice of chapter II.5 in his book Cohomology of groups. He suggests a more topological approach, and here is an attempt to do it:

Let $\langle X \mid R \rangle$ be a presentation of a group $G$ with $|X|=n$ and $|R|=m$. Let also $r$ denote $\mathrm{rk}_{\mathbb{Z}} G^{ab}$. We want to prove that $\mathrm{rk}_{\mathbb{Z}} H_2(G) \leq r-n+m$.

Let $Y$ be the CW-complex associated to the given presentation. It is known that it is possible to add $n$-cells to $Y$, with $n \geq 3$, in order to "kill" higher homotopy groups. More precisely, the new CW-complex $Y^{\mathrm{aug}}$ satisfies $\pi_n ( Y^{\mathrm{aug}}) = 0$ for all $n\geq 2$. Moreover, because we did not modify the $2$-squeleton of $Y$, $\pi_1(Y) \simeq \pi_1( Y^{\mathrm{aug}})$. Therefore, $Y^{\mathrm{aug}}$ is a $K(G,1)$, hence $H_{\ast}(Y^{\mathrm{aug}}) \simeq H_{\ast} (G)$.

Notice that $1-n+m = \chi(Y)= 1- \mathrm{rk}_{\mathbb{Z}} H_1(Y) + \mathrm{rk}_{\mathbb{Z}} H_2(Y)$, hence $\mathrm{rk}_{\mathbb{Z}} H_2(Y)=r-n+m$.

On the other hand, we clearly have an epimorphism $H_2(Y) \twoheadrightarrow H_2(Y^{\mathrm{aug}})$, therefore:

$$\mathrm{rk}_{\mathbb{Z}} H_2(G)= \mathrm{rk}_{\mathbb{Z}} H_2( Y^{\mathrm{aug}}) \leq \mathrm{rk}_{\mathbb{Z}} H_2(Y)=r-n+m.$$


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.