Suppose $\mathcal{C}$ is a category and $f: A \rightarrow B $ is a morphism from an object $A$ to another object $B$ such that $f_*:Hom(C,A) \to Hom(C,B)$ is bijective $\forall C \in ob(\mathcal{C})$. Can it be concluded that $f$ is an equivalence ? I am able to see that $\exists g: B \to A$ such that $fg=id_B$ but am unable to find an $h$ such that $hf=id_A$. We can assume that the category is small if it helps. If it is not true, how can we find a counterexample ? Thanks


Yes indeed, you just found the famous Yoneda Lemma (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yoneda_lemma). Concretely, while you only needed surjectivity of $f_{\ast}$ to deduce the existence of $g: B\to A$ with $fg=\text{id}_B$, you can use injectivity to deduce from $f_{\ast}(gf)=f(gf)=(fg)f=\text{id}_B\ f=f\ \text{id}_A=f_{\ast}(\text{id}_A)$ that $gf=\text{id}_A$ as well, hence $g$ is a two-sided inverse of $f$.

Addendum concerning the relation to the Yoneda Lemma:

The Yoneda-Lemma says that for any category ${\mathscr C}$ the Yoneda-functor $${\mathbb Y}: {\mathscr C}\to\text{Func}({\mathscr C}^{\text{op}},\textsf{Set}), \quad X\mapsto{\mathbb Y}(X) := \text{Hom}_{{\mathscr C}}(-,X)$$ is fully faithful. In particular - as does any fully faithful functor - it reflects isomorphisms.

Now, your assumption is that for all $C\in{\mathscr C}$ the map $f_{\ast}:\text{Hom}_{\mathscr C}(C,X)\to \text{Hom}_{\mathscr C}(C,Y)$ is bijective, which means that the morphism ${\mathbb Y}(f): {\mathbb Y}(X)\to{\mathbb Y}(Y)$ of functors ${\mathscr C}^{\text{op}}\to\textsf{Set}$ is a pointwise isomorphism. However, pointwise isomorphisms of functors are already isomorphisms (check this), so your assumption implies that ${\mathbb Y}(f)$ is an isomorphism, and hence so is $f$.

  • $\begingroup$ Thanks ! I understood the concrete argument you gave and this solves my problem. However I could not relate it to Yoneda lemma, could you please elaborate a bit ? Thanks $\endgroup$ – user90041 Jan 15 '15 at 19:08
  • $\begingroup$ I added some details now. $\endgroup$ – Hanno Jan 15 '15 at 19:23

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.