For any three positive scales, $a,b,c$, what is the sufficient and necessary condition such that they can form a triangle? Is $a+c>b,a+b>c,b+c>a$ enough? Thanks!



$a=x+y,\ b=y+z,\ c=z+x\land x,y,z\in \mathbb{R^+}$


$a=x+y,\ b=y+z,\ c=z+x$

$a+b>c \implies x+2y+z>z+x \implies y>0$

$b+c>a \implies z>0$

$c+a>b \implies x>0$


$y>0 \implies x+2y+z>z+x \implies a+b>c$

$z>0 \implies y+2z+x>x+y \implies b+c>a$

$x>0\implies z+2x+y>y+z\implies c+a>b$

| cite | improve this answer | |

Assertion: The system of inequality is both necessary and sufficient, for the existence of a triangle with side lengths = a, b and c.


-- Necessity

The shortest path between any two points is the straight line connecting such two points.

-- Sufficiency

Rank the three numbers. Without loss of generality, let a be the number that is no smaller than the other two, i.e. a >= b and a >= c.

At any point O, draw two concentric circles with radius a and b respectively. (OK for them to coincide in the case of a = b.)

Draw a horizontal diameter intersecting the outer circle at Al(eft) and Ar(ight), inner circle at Bl and Br.

Then distance AlBl = a-b and AlBr = a+b. Since a-b < c < a+b, then, by continuity, there must exist a point on the inner circle (denoted as B) such that AlB = c.

Further, points Al, O and B cannot possibly be co-linear (on a straight line) as that would imply that a = b + c.

Al-O-B thus forms the desired triangle.


| cite | improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.