I know $\sigma(m)=24$ for $m\in\{14,15,23\}$ but how can we find these numbers?

Here is what I did:
Let the prime factorization of $m$ be $$m=p_1 ^{\alpha _{1}}p_2 ^{\alpha _{2}}\cdot\cdot\cdot p_k ^{\alpha _{k}}.$$
Now $24=2\cdot2\cdot2\cdot3,$ thus $k\leq4.$

Case 1: $k=1$ $$m=p_1 ^{\alpha _{1}}$$ Taking $\alpha _{1}=1$ gives $p_1 =23 \implies m=23.$

But what happens if $\alpha _{1}=2,3,4,...$? Is there a bound for $\alpha _{1}$? What about the other cases $k=\{2,3,4\}?$


If your entire goal is to find those numbers $n$ satisfying $\sigma_1(n) = 24$, then it is easiest to just look at all the numbers up to $23$ one by one.

You can throw out $1$ and all the primes before $23$, leaving only $4,6,8,9,10,12,14,15,16,18,20,21,22$ (and $23$, which clearly has divisor sum $24$).

With regard to your method, you might notice that you've actually shown that the number of primes occurring with full multiplicity is at most $4$. In principle, this might be helpful. But in practice, every number up to $24$ has prime multiplicity at most $4$, so this bit of naivete isn't helpful. If you assume two primes, then you have one of the cases $p_1^3p_2$ or $p_1^2p_2^2$. The process of checking whether you can choose primes such that the corresponding divisor sums becomes $24$ starts to look more and more knapsackish, and therefore scary.


For relatively prime $m,n, \sigma(mn) = \sigma(m) * \sigma(n)$. And there aren't that many factor pairs that produce 24.

$$1\times24$$ $$2\times12$$ $$3\times8$$ $$4\times6$$

For prime $p$, $\sigma(p) = p + 1$, and luckily enough 23 is prime. That takes care of the $1\times24$ case.

There is no number that has a sum of factors of 2, so the $2\times12$ pair isn't useful.

The third factor pair is useful, as $\sigma(2) = 3$ and $\sigma(7) = 8$. That means that $\sigma(2\times7)=\sigma(14)=24$.

Similarly, $\sigma(3)\times\sigma(5)=4\times6 = \sigma(15)$. And as we're out of factor pairs, we're done searching for other numbers that satisfy the equation.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.