2014 Moderator Election

nomination began
Dec 8 '14 at 20:00
primary began
Dec 15 '14 at 20:00
election began
Dec 19 '14 at 20:00
election ended
Dec 23 '14 at 20:00
candidates
20 / 23
positions
3

On Stack Exchange, we believe the core moderators should come from the community, and be elected by the community itself through popular vote. We hold regular elections to determine who these community moderators will be.

See a theory of moderation for the typical roles and abilities of a moderator. Once elected, moderators may hold the position as long as they wish, unless they become inactive or exhibit gross misbehavior.

Community moderators are accorded the highest level of privilege and trust on our community, and should themselves be exemplars of positive behavior within the community. Our general criteria for moderators is as follows:

  • patient and fair
  • leads by example
  • shows respect for their fellow community members in their actions and words
  • open to some light but firm moderation to keep the community on track and resolve (hopefully) uncommon disputes and exceptions

Every election has three phases:

  1. Nomination
  2. Primary
  3. Election

Depending on the number of nominees that enter, and the number of moderator positions to be filled, in some circumstances the election may skip the Primary phase and proceed directly to the Election phase.

Please participate in the moderator elections by voting, and perhaps even by nominating yourself to be a community moderator!


Daniel's answers to your questions


After a long deliberation, I have decided that I too am ready to take up some obligations to help keep maintaining and if possible increasing the quality of the site by becoming a moderator (if elected).

I am a relatively new user of this site, but since I've joined about one and a half years ago, I have been fairly active here - mostly answering questions and posting hopefully helpful comments, but I have also been moderately active in the review queues and done a bit of editing posts into better shape, and cast a couple of flags, so I am not completely without experience in the janitorial tasks. My meta experience is mostly reading, but occasionally I muster the energy to answer a question there too.

There are some things that make me think I would be a good moderator:

  • I am old enough to be patient, so the risk of me losing my temper is small.
  • I care enough about the site to invest a significant amount of time in it.

And others that make me doubt:

  • I am a slow thinker and slow at coming to decisions.
  • I lack skill at "putting myself in the other's shoes".
  • I have no previous moderation experience.

It may be relevant (or not) that I'm not a professional mathematician.

13

Jyrki's answers to your questions


Reporting for janitorial duty.

I have been at our site for three and a half years now and I'm totally addicted. Might as well try and give something back to the best math site I've ever seen.

The main reasons why I think I am a good choice are:

  • Math/career experience. I have been exposed to diverse corners of math, educational systems on both sides of the Atlantic, 25 years of teaching at college/university level, as well as interfacing with programmers/telcomm engineers during my shortish industry stint.
  • I like to think I'm moderate (don't we all?). I will occasionally get caught in a heated debate. But after the initial shockwave has passed I try to bury the hatchet and look for a compromise.

IMO my major shortcomings are:

  • Lack of time elsewhere in the SE network. I have never participated in our network wide meta, and thus I only have second hand exposure to SE philosophy. The moderators are our main link to SE staff, so I will have a lot to learn there. I have never moderated a site before.
  • I'm not sure about the level of my emotional intelligence - you be the judge.

If given a bigger broom to wield I will be more careful about how, when and where I sweep.

6

Ilmari's answers to your questions


I'm a 34-year-old PhD student in biomathematics at the University of Helsinki. I've been active on Math.SE, and the SE network in general, since 2011.

I have diverse interests, and I'm active on a lot of SE sites, including SO, Meta.SE, Crypto.SE, Physics, Academia and Math Educators (and, of course, Math.SE). Outside SE, I've been a Wikipedia admin since 2006 (although I haven't been active there for years), so I know a bit about what's involved in moderating a large volunteer-driven open content collaboration.

IMO, the job of a moderator is to keep the site running smoothly. That involves several things:

  • On one hand, a moderator is a janitor — someone who makes sure the floors stay clean, someone you call in when the toilet is overflowing.

  • The other part of a moderator's job is to moderate — to step in when tempers get too hot and ensure that, despite our differences and misunderstandings, we all mostly get along.

I've been told that I have an even temperament. I rarely get angry or upset, and I try to empathize with both sides in a dispute — a trait I hope to put to good use as a community moderator.

6

Arkamis's answers to your questions


I would like to nominate myself as a moderator candidate in these elections.

As a career researcher but non-academic, my background in mathematics involves a great deal of interfacing with non-mathematicians. To this end, I have a strong belief that quality of communication is as important as technical detail, both in providing answers and in asking questions. I believe that simply providing an answer is often insufficient, either because it goes beyond the user's comprehension, or because it fails to promote a context for further understanding. As a corollary, I also believe that blandly asking a question without communicating prior understanding or context is equally undesirable.

In over two years of participation on this site, I have grown to appreciate the concept of mathematics as community. I think that this is a strong community of learning, but also of sharing, and that quality of the community is strengthened by the ability to participate in both.

As a moderator, my emphasis would be on community building, by supporting members who add diversity and genuine interest, and by discouraging those users who seek to use the community only for their own sake.

25

mick's answers to your questions


Ive been around here for 2 years and I learned to improve my communication skills about math subjects. I did not want to nominate myself in the past because I felt I was not ready. But now I learned some math and also how to talk about it. I gained experience and insight. I think Im ready for some moderation now.

I reached 2450+ reputation and that is a sign for me Im ready. ALthough Im very young (15) im intrested in many areas of math , even the less popular or wellknown ones. (such as tetration)

Im aware Im far from the best mathematician but I am also far from the worst :) I consider myself to have the wisdom to know what I understand and to know what I do not. And thus I think I know when I should leave things to others when Im not the right person to act.

As a person I think I can call myself openminded and constructive. I would prefer to comment or edit , then to vote to close or delete for instance.

I think everyone who is serious about math and gives a sincere attempt at a good question or answer deserves constructive comment and an explaination for negative feedback.

Also I love MSE :)

3

dustin's answers to your questions


I have been a member here for 1.5 years but have only recently started to ask and answer questions on the site. However, I have been an active member on TeX stackechange for 1.9 years.

As a moderator, I would be fair and just. I come on the site to answer questions that interest me, learn, and ask questions; that is, I am not here to socialize. Due to the not socializing nature, I don't hold any favoritism towards any other member which in turn would allow me to be fair.

I currently hold a BS in Math and Finance (2011) and a MS in Mechanical Engineering (2014). I hope to be pursing a PhD in Electrical Engineering in the fall of 2015 or if I can't find a job I both enjoy and pays well, I would consider that too.

When I am not on the site, I go hiking in the mountains of Vermont and New Hampshire during the winter months since the views are amazing and the trails aren't crowded. When I am not on the mountains, I will be in the gym or reading.

30

I accept that I have a reasonably "low reputation" and do not deserve to hold the moderator post in that sense but I promise that my services would not be as low as my reputation.The thing which I like the most is Maths and Maths is my GOD.So whatever I would do would be just what is right for Maths.With the dedication of me to Maths and the math stacexchange site which has paved a way for me to explore the infinite world of maths I promise that I would -

1 Treat everyone equal whether it be the highest reputed member or one who is a newcomer to this site.

2 Would try my best that questions are not closed or marked as off-topic without any proper reason which has been the complain of many members.

3 Would be humble to all and try my best that I never hurt anyone's feelings or self respect

4 Would answer everyone's queries and welcome all sorts of doubts

And at last I would try to make this site a fruitful one with my full dedication so that even the one who hates Maths starts loving it via this site .

6

TODO: answer questions from the voters


I think I can distinguish good answers with effort put in them from ones which are not, and provide assistance in elementary subjects. I usually care about what I see on the site and overseeing and correcting things when I think its necessary is important to me.

8

TODO: answer questions from the voters


I have been around here since 9 months ago, I have learned and know how the system here works. Although my contribution on Math SE is very small compared to the prominent users here, considering my age and the little time I've been here, I think it is not negligible. I have enough experience because I have participated in many similar sites like Math SE (you may refer to my profile page for the details).

I have learned so much from this site and I think it is about time for me to give back. While Mr. Martin Sleziak has said that I can still contribute to the growth of this community, in some ways and in my own schedule, even without my diamond, serving as a moderator will give me bigger chances to improve my contributions than as an ordinary user. I have good enough mathematics skills, I like to get along with the users here, and most importantly, I have a lot of time to serve this site.

I hope I am not making any immodest statements, excessively praising myself, nor showing narcissism on my part. Thank you and may God bless Mathematics StackExchange.

Addendum : Please take a look this one too. Thanks.

26

Shaun's answers to your questions.


Keen to award bounties, I care more about having an actual reputation than having a high rep count. I am in favour of quality over quantity, questions of value that demonstrate an eagerness to learn, and honest answers with depth & clarity.

See for yourself the effort I put into my questions and answers.

I am a Masters student in the UK looking to take my mathematics to Ph.D. level and beyond, and I care more about the subject than I care to admit.

In some respects, I'm already moderating the site more than most. Consider the following review, flag, and attendance figures:

  • First Post: 1103.
  • Low Quality Post: 1105.
  • Late Answer: 33.
  • Suggested Edit: 639.
  • Visited: 407 days, 407 consecutive.
  • Helpful Flags (Mathematics SE): 885.

If I become a moderator: I will endeavour to uphold the high standards MSE is already performing to, and then some; I will continue to encourage excellent posts all round; and I will exercise to the best of my ability a forgiving, fair, and firm approach to moderating.

Please vote for me :)

Thank you for your time.

7

Coming from a strictly neutral country - Switzerland - I think I have the ideal predisposition to be a moderator :)

I'm a math enthusiast, and I like to get along with people. I'm active on MathOverflow as well as on math.stackexchange.com and I've experience in teaching as well as research.

1

Ahaan's answers to your questions


Besides being a complete mathematics addict, I am also very adhered to Math.StackExchange. Here are some reasons I think I would be a good fit for the moderator position.

  1. I have past experience, especially with being a mod on AoPS and Brilliant and have other leadership positions, all of which have been extremely enjoyable and successful.

  2. My maturity and understanding for others exceeds my age, IMHO.

  3. My love for the community and care for the site would not interfere with my position; I would not let the users control my actions and would keep my power under the backseat until the time comes that I must use it.

There are a copious number of reasons for which I want to be a moderator, but primarily, it is to give back. In my 18 months on Math.SE, I have encountered many people of several statures spending several hours of their time helping others and I, myself, have used that help, and have provided a lot of help. As an active question-asker and problem-solver, I take any misuse of the site very seriously and I want to help the community as much as possible. Now is my chance to serve back.

Good luck to all!

13

Jack's answers to your questions


I think to have all the traits to be a good moderator and I would like to improve my contribute to such a great community. I am quite proud for the creation of the bessel-functions tag and for many answers I gave, especially about harmonic number identities, special functions, sequence and series. I learned much on this site and I think it is time to bring my participation - that was quite massive, especially in the last six months, when I gained about 20k reputation points, to a new level, more useful for the whole community.

About closing question, I am more willing to improve the improvable. I am for closing questions that sound like "please do my homework", but to leave open interesting questions, even in the case that the OP shows little efforts.

I care much about the efficiency of MSE: it would be great to avoid duplicate questions and make every content easy to find. To be a moderator is just a way to achieve a more direct control on the overall quality of this huge resource.

I got a 32 in the recent Citizenship score query.

14

Pedro's answers to your questions


I've been around this site for almost 3 years now. I've been in a math undergraduate program for that time, too. Being the most active user in the the (official?) chat room (with around 90 thousand messages so far) it is highly probable you'll find me there. I'd like to believe this is also accompanied by quality in my answers and posts.

I generally do some work related to changing titles, tags, adding TeX, and guiding the OP to either producing a better post or a solution to his/her problem. I comment quite a lot, sometimes for the better, sometimes for the worse. I have had my quarrels with some users, and quarrel with some in chat, but this happens in a more facetious manner. I have probably been suspended from chat a few times.

Ideally, I would want MSE to make users understand there's a certain "quality of user" the community is expecting: show your work, explain your ideas, code your TeX, choose appropriate titles, engage in discussion in comments, welcome criticism, criticize.

Regarding closing issues, I usually close "closable" questions. This is sometimes seen as a bad thing, but personally, it's the best way for people to improve their post quality.

10

TODO: answer questions from the voters


I have been an active member on various stackexchange sites for a little over one year. My main interest though is in the mathematics exchange. I am a mathematician myself and can greatly benefit from answering questions on this site. It is basically an exercise for myself to improve my own mathematical skills, and to learn the proper didactics of teaching maths and formulating answers to questions in a comprehensible way.

Throughout my time here I learned the rules and guidelines and the "dos and don'ts" of the community. I enjoy the point system and see it as a challenge to myself to write good contributions and thereby increasing my points and earn badges. And I enjoy reading new questions and answers and reviewing them, editing and formatting some and so on.

I try to be consistently active on the site. It depends on my real life workload, but as it is the same field, I can almost always find some time.

I would be happy to be accepted as a moderator of the exchange.

Thank you for your consideration

1

The StackExchange platform, and in particular the Mathematics website, is very dear to me. Nowhere on the web, one can say it is common to get a reaction to a post within a few minutes, not to say a few seconds sometimes.

Such a dynamic community is, mostly, built and maintained by people who are all doing it on the side. These small contributions really add up and make a big difference in helping people on their way, via collaboration in the form of feedback.

In my past experience, I have come to learn the ethics of the Mathematics SE website and the other SE websites. By reading posts as how to write a good question and now and then touching on some soft questions and the meta websites.

Hence I believe that I am eligible to take on the responsibility of the moderator role.

4

This election is over.