83 reputation
6
bio website
location
age
visits member for 2 months
seen 14 hours ago
stats profile views 9

May
16
comment Functoriality of the Fundamental group
@Dan. Sure - that was a poorly worded comment. For example something like $BS^3$ is probably not an E-M space
May
16
comment Why base point makes a huge difference?
It's a Dover book, and you can get it for around $10 (or an equivalent in your local currency!)
May
16
comment filtration on the (co)homology of a space from the filtration of a space
I wouldn't look at the Serre spectral sequence part. I'd just look up the section on the spectral sequence associated to a filtered complex.
May
16
comment Functoriality of the Fundamental group
What if we take, for example, $G=S^1$?. Then $BG = K(\mathbb{Z},2)$. $BG$ is not always an E-M space
May
15
comment What is $\pi_{31}(S^2)$?
I think the 64 refers to Kochman's work, but he was working stably. The tables of Toda only go out to 19.
May
15
awarded  Commentator
May
15
comment Why base point makes a huge difference?
Oh OK! You can also find a nice proof in Mosher & Tangora's book (if you can find a copy)
May
15
comment Why base point makes a huge difference?
I'm not sure why you don't feel comfortable. Principal $S^1$ bundles are in correspondence with maps $[X,\mathbb{C} P^\infty] = [X,K(\mathbb{Z},2)]$. Since the Eilenberg-Maclane spaces represent homology this is just $H^2(X;\mathbb{Z}) = \mathbb{Z}$ for a surface.
May
14
comment Why base point makes a huge difference?
@user32240: $\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z} = S^1$
May
14
comment Why base point makes a huge difference?
When you write $[Z,Y]$ be you mean based on unbased homotopy classes of maps?
May
14
comment Why base point makes a huge difference?
I think you have your example backwards. $B\mathbb{Z} = S^1$. $BS^1 = \mathbb{C}P^\infty$
May
14
comment Tor and flat base change
Thanks Tyler. I agree with what you are saying. (I emailed Rotman and it appears it is just an error in the book)
May
12
awarded  Teacher
May
12
answered Spectral sequences: equivalence of exact couples and classic (?) method
Mar
6
awarded  Scholar
Mar
6
awarded  Supporter
Mar
6
accepted Tor and flat base change
Feb
28
comment Tor and flat base change
Right. Which is exactly what Rotman (seems to be) assuming
Feb
28
awarded  Editor
Feb
28
comment Tor and flat base change
Thanks. I've always thought this was the case. The proof he gives is definitely only on one side. I've sketched it above, along with the part that I don't quite see.