# Tagged Questions

34 views

### How much arithmetic can Predicative Second-Order EFA do?

As discussed in this MathOverflow question, I'm trying to find what the result would be of applying a Feferman-Scutte-like analysis to the predicativism of Edward Nelson and Charles Parsons, who ...
75 views

### How can we define infinitary proofs?

In the first order logic the usual notion of a formal proof for a sentence $\sigma$ from a theory $T$ is a "finite" sequence ($<\omega$ - sequeance) of sentences which each one of them is a valid ...
67 views

### Type Theory (Proof tree)

Suppose $B(x)$ set $(x:A)$ is a family of sets and $D$ is a set. Prove $(\Sigma x:A)B(x) \times D \to (\Sigma x:A)(B(x) \times D)$. Using the so called Curry-Howard correspondence one may ...
36 views

### Induction on Primitive Recursive Function

The set $F_{n}$ of primitive recursive function symbols of arity $n$ can be defined inductively as: \begin{align} & Z, \text{Succ} \in F_{1} & \\ &\pi_{j}^{n} \in F_{n} \quad \text{for ...
75 views

### Curry-Howard Correspondence (Proof Theory)

As you all know, the Curry-Howard correspondance provides a link between type theory and predicate logic. Concepts featured in the former, such as $\Pi$-type and $\Sigma$-type can, by the ...
60 views

### Given a theorem can it always be reduced logically to the axioms?

It's probably a silly question but I’ve been carrying this one since infancy so i might as well ask it already. let ($p \implies q$) be a theorem where $p$ is the hypotheses and $q$ is the ...
105 views

### Minimal difference between classical and intuitionistic sequent calculus

Consider propositional logic with primitive connectives $\{{\to},{\land},{\lor},{\bot}\}$. We view $\neg \varphi$ as an abbreviation of $\varphi\to\bot$ and $\varphi\leftrightarrow\psi$ as an ...
48 views

64 views

### Unprovable unprovability of $\forall x\in X:P(x)$

Consider statements of the form $\forall x\in X:P(x)$. Is it possible that such a statement is proven to be unprovable? I think not, and here is my argument: if we proved that the statement is ...
113 views

### True and provably true sentences in a model. Are they the same thing?

In logic, it is said that each sentence in a (consistent) theory is either true or false in a given model. Checking the truth of a sentence in a finite model amounts essentially to finite enumeration ...
53 views

### Is the Church-Kleene Ordinal describable with Kleene's $O$?

Kleene's $O$ is an ordinal notation system that uses certain natural numbers to represent transfinite ordinals. It is a recursive notation system (although it's not decidable whether a number ...
58 views

### Is ordinal analysis a non-recursive project?

A recursive ordinal is an ordinal that is the order-type for some recursive relation (i.e. a recursive well-ordering). We can represent recursive ordinals as natural numbers using Kleene's $O$, an ...
107 views

### What is the proof-theoretic ordinal of the first-order theory of real closed fields?

I recently asked a question on MathOverflow, concerning a predicative second-order theory of real numbers. Now the standard way of developing predicativity in the case of second-order arithmetic is ...
99 views

### Simple proof theory - Propositional Logic

When addressing the questions, which are featured below, I use the following definition and two lemmas. Definition: $\phi$ is a tautology if $[[\phi]]_{v}=1$ for all valuations $v$. Moreover, ...
43 views

### Is the converse of the first Hilbert-Bernays Derivability Condition true?

The first Hilbert-Bernays Derivability Condition is (⊢P) → (⊢◻P). What I'd like to know is, is the converse true? That is, is (⊢◻P) → (⊢P) valid? I know from Löb's Theorem that ⊢(◻P → P) is not valid ...
118 views

### Qns on Propositional Logic - Inference Rules + Logical Equivalence

Have been working on this for the past 2 hours and still not getting any where. Any help will be much appreciated! Consider the following argument 1) p 2) p v q 3) q → (r → s) 4) t → r ∴¬s → ¬t ...
55 views

### Epistemic disjunction, axiom or rule?

Assume I have a minimal logic |- with disjunction v and implication ->. Now I want to represent some domain knowledge. One opponent says I should represent it as an axiom: ...
142 views

### How can arithmetic express claims of the form $\Sigma \vdash \sigma$ when $\Sigma$ is infinite?

As an example, let $\Sigma$ denote the axioms of ZFC (an infinite set). It is my understanding that the language of arithmetic can be used to express claims of the form $$\Sigma \vdash \sigma$$ where ...
82 views