Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I am a little confused as to why sometimes they will treat $x$ in $\ln x$ as $\ln ab$ and other times its treated as $\ln x$.... To be more clear, here is an example:

$2\ln(3x^2-1)$ and $\ln2x$. Now, in $2\ln(3x^2-1)$ the $3x^2-1$ becomes $x$ and is written as $2\cdot1/x\cdot x'$. My question is why? because this could have been treated as $\ln3x^2/\ln1$.

On the other hand, $\ln2x$ they solve as $\ln2+\ln x$ then differentiate it.... So my question is: When do they choose to apply the log rules and when not to? Will not applying the rule give you the wrong answer? In the case of $2\ln(3x^2-1)$ could they have done it differently as oppose to treating $3x^2-1$ as $x$.

share|improve this question
    
I think you may want to rewrite parts of this. It's incomprehensible as it is now. I assume lnx is $\ln x$, but what's lnab? And the second paragraph is completely unreadable. –  Mike Dec 8 '11 at 15:48

3 Answers 3

up vote 1 down vote accepted

I hope that the following comments settle some of your questions. Unfortunately, it is not clear what notation you use for the Chain Rule.

1) Suppose that $H(x)=\ln(5x)$. We want to find $H'(x)$. Note that $\ln(5x)$ is "function of a function of $x$." Specifically, $\ln(5x)=f(g(x)$, where $g(x)=5x$ and $f(u)=\ln(u)$.

Therefore, by the Chain Rule, we have $H'(x)=g'(x)f'(g(x))$. Note that $g'(x)=5$ and $f'(u)=\dfrac{1}{u}$. So $f'(g(x))=\dfrac{1}{5x}$.

Now put things together. We have $H'(x)=(5)\dfrac{1}{5x}$. This simplifies to $\dfrac{1}{x}$.

In this case, we could have avoided the Chain Rule, by noting that $H(x)=\ln(5x)=\ln(5)+\ln(x)$. Differentiate, using the fact that $\ln(5)$ is a constant and therefore its derivative is $0$. We get $H'(x)=\dfrac{1}{x}$.

2) Let $H(x)=\ln(3x^2-1)$. We want $H'(x)$. Note that $H(x)=f(g(x))$ where $g(x)=3x^2-1$ and $f(u)=\ln(u)$. Use the Chain Rule like before. We have $g'(x)=6x$ and $f'(u)=\dfrac{1}{u}$. Putting things together like before, we get $H'(x)=\dfrac{6x}{3x^2-1}$. No useful simplification is available.

Important note: It looks as if your post asks why we can't treat $\ln(3x^2-1)$ as $\dfrac{\ln(3x^2)}{\ln(1)}$.

The reason that we can't is that $\ln(3x^2-1)$ is not equal to $\dfrac{\ln(3x^2)}{\ln(1)}$. The logarithm of a product is a sum of logarithms. the logarithm of a quotient is a difference of logarithms. So for example, $\ln((x^2+1)(x^2+5))=\ln(x^2+1)+\ln(x^2+5)$, and $\ln(7/5)=\ln(7)-\ln(5)$.

But the logarithm of a sum can't be "simplified" in a pleasant way, and neither can the logarithm of a difference. You can check for yourself, with a calculator, that $\ln(7-2)$ is not equal to $\dfrac{\ln(7)}{\ln(2)}.$

If you use the FALSE "rules" $\ln(a+b)=\ln(a)+\ln(b)$ or $\ln(a-b)=\dfrac{\ln(a)}{\ln(b)}$, it will cause you grief over and over.

share|improve this answer

$\ln(3x^2-1)$ is certainly not the same as $\ln(3x^2)/(\ln 1)$.

Correct: $\ln\dfrac ab=(\ln a) - (\ln b)$

Incorrect: $\ln(a-b) = \dfrac{\ln a}{\ln b}$

share|improve this answer
    
thank you all! i would logically think that the sum or difference rules for ln exist but they dont! –  Raynos Dec 8 '11 at 20:54

Now, in $2\ln(3x^2-1)$ the $3x^2-1$ becomes $x$ and is written as $2\cdot1/x\cdot x'$.

I'll assume you mean it's treated as another variable (not $x$), perhaps $u$, and you differentiate $2\ln u$ to obtain $2\cdot\frac1uu'$ (which is then $2\cdot\frac1{3x^2-1}6x$.

The answer is that it doesn't matter. You can do either method in either case. But whereas $\ln 2x$ is easy to split up into $\ln2+\ln x$, $\ln(3x^2-1)$ is not as easy to split up — see Michael Hardy's answer — so they don't split it up. (But if you'd find a way to split it up, you could.)

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.