Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

So suppose I want a path from 0 to $c>0$ on the real line, and I am going to use the function $S(t)$ to get there in (discrete) time $T$. That is, my position at time 0 is 0, my position at time $T$ is $c$, and my position $P_t$ changes in the following way:

$$ P_t = (1-\gamma) P_{t-1} + \gamma S(t) $$ where $\gamma<1$ limits fast I can move. Which can be written $$ \frac{P_t - P_{t-1}}{\gamma} = - P_{t-1} +S(t) $$

Sadly, I have a drift towards zero of $-P$, and $S$ has to drive me away from zero, towards $c$. So $S(t)$ is the "size" of my push towards $c$ at date $t$. The cost of $S$ is given by

$$ C(T,S(t)) = \sum_1^{T} (S(t))^2 $$ So I am penalized for large movements in my position, and big pushes towards $c$. I would like to calculate $$ \min_{T,S(\cdot)} C(T,S(t)) $$ subject to $P_0 =0$, $P_T = c$.

That is, if I am free to choose the number of steps it takes to get there, and the path can be whatever I want, what is the cost minimizing route from 0 to $c$?

Clearly, you could set $S(1) = c / \gamma$, so I arrive immediately, at cost $( c/\gamma )^2$. So that is an upper bound on the cost. I could do it in two steps; If I step $x$ the first period, I will need to step $$\frac{(c-(1-\gamma) \gamma x)}{\gamma}$$ the second period, for a total cost of of $$ x^2 + (\frac{(c-(1-\gamma) \gamma x)}{\gamma})^2, $$ Which is minimized for $x=\frac{c (1-\gamma)}{\gamma (2-2 \gamma+\gamma^2 )}$, which therefore costs $$ \frac{c^2 (1-\gamma)^2}{\gamma^2 (2-2 \gamma+\gamma^2)^2}+\frac{(c+\frac{c (1-\gamma) (-1+\gamma)}{2-2 \gamma+\gamma^2})^2}{\gamma^2} $$ which is a lower cost than the one-step option, since $\gamma<1$. It is not clear to me how to extend this analysis to large $T$ - is there a simple recursive form for the cost minimizing $k$-step path, and the problem reduces to choosing the best $k$?

share|cite|improve this question
up vote 3 down vote accepted

For fixed $T$, or $k$ which is the same thing, it turns out that you are just minimizing a quadratic function with a linear constraint, and a simple solution exists. However, there is no best $k$ -- you can make the cost arbitrarily small by taking longer and longer to get there.

Let $s$ be the vector with components $s_i = S(i)$ for $i = 1, \ldots, k$. Then if you expand out the recursion in your first equation $P_k = \gamma s_k + (1-\gamma) P_{k-1}$, you will find that $$\begin{align} P_k &= \sum_{i=1}^k \gamma(1-\gamma)^{k-i} s_i + (1-\gamma)^k P_0 \\ &= b^Ts + 0 \end{align}$$ where $b$ is a vector whose components are $b_i = \gamma(1-\gamma)^{k-i}$. So your problem is that of minimizing $C(s) = \sum_{i=1}^k s_i^2 = s^Ts$, subject to the constraint $b^Ts = c$. Using Lagrange multipliers, you can get a straightforward solution. However, you will find that the cost decreases asymptotically with $k$.

share|cite|improve this answer
Great answer, I didn't see the essential linearity of the constraint. – Dennis Nov 2 '10 at 13:05

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.