Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

In Chapter 7 of Marcus' Number Fields, he defines the polar density of a set $A$ of primes of a number field $K$ as follows:

Definition: If some $n$th power of the function $$\zeta_{K,A}(s) = \prod_{P \in A} \left(1-\frac{1}{\|P\|^s} \right)^{-1}$$ can be extended to a meromorphic function in a neighborhood of $s=1$, having a pole of order $m$ at $s=1$, then the polar density of $A$ is $\delta(A) = \dfrac{m}{n}$.

Are there any relatively easily describable sets of primes such that this density would not be defined?

share|cite|improve this question
Since this definition of density is always rational, would you be interested in a set of primes with irrational density? – Erick Wong Jul 12 '12 at 22:36
@ErickWong at least I would be interested in such a set. Go ahead, please... – draks ... Jul 14 '12 at 9:00
up vote 3 down vote accepted

We might as well restrict to $K=\mathbb Q$, so that $\zeta_A(s) = \prod_{p\in A} (1 - p^{-s})^{-1}$. If the polar density of $A$ exists, then the Dirichlet density exists and is equal. In particular, if the natural density and polar density of $A$ both exist, then they must be the same.

Since the definition of polar density is only capable of producing rational numbers, it suffices to name a set of primes $A$ having a natural density that is irrational.

I can think of several natural sets of primes which should have irrational density, but I haven't thought of one that is both aesthetically pleasing and of provably irrational density.

Some incomplete examples:

  • The set of primes with $p-1$ squarefree has density equal to Artin's constant $\prod_p (1-\frac{1}{p(p-1)})$, see Artin's constant is presumed but not known to be irrational.
  • The set of primes for which $p-1$ has a prime factor greater than $\sqrt{p}$ is conjectured to be $\log 2$, which is the exact density of integers $n$ possessing a similar property.

Of course it is possible to describe less succinctly a set of primes having any density in $[0,1]$. I still wonder if there is a simple variation that will give an obviously irrational singular series constant like $6/\pi^2$.

Another approach is to take a sparse set of primes for which $\prod_p(1-1/p)^{-1}$ still diverges slowly (for instance, if the counting function is $x/(\log x \log \log x)$). This will have natural density $0$, but the singularity at $s=1$ prevents $\zeta_A(s)$ from being continued to a holomorphic function in a neighbourhood of $1$ (by a result of Landau).

The disjoint union of such a set with one already having polar density should also lack a polar density, even with a rational natural density.

share|cite|improve this answer
+1 and Thx for your answer. How is the sparse set of primes defined? Can you give an explicite example? – draks ... Jul 16 '12 at 9:17

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.