Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

For $n\geq 7$, I would like to show that $S_n$ has no irredicuble representations of dimension $m$ for $2\leq m\leq n-2$.

The catch is that I am not allowed to use any "machinery" (evidently, this problem should be solvable having knowledge only of chapter 1 of Fulton and Harris).

At the moment, I don't really have any idea of how to approach this, especially without the use of character theory. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated!

share|improve this question
This is not true. The tensor product of the sign representation and the standard has dimension $n-1$, and is not isomorphic to the standard. –  David Speyer Oct 2 '11 at 23:55
Thanks David. I'll edit the post to take this into account. –  Jonathan Gleason Oct 2 '11 at 23:58
The case $n=7$ seems easy. Look at a 7-cycle. If it has a primitive seventh root as an eigenvalue, then it must have all six of them as eigenvalues, because it is conjugate to its non-trivial powers. That alone forces the dimension to be at least 6. OTOH if 1 is the sole eigenvalue, then all the 7-cycles would act trivially. Hence so would the subgroup that they generate, which is $A_7$... Alas, I cannot generalize this argument to higher $n$. –  Jyrki Lahtonen Oct 3 '11 at 4:46
What about proving by induction that the only small irreducible reps of $S_n$ are the listed ones: two 1-dimensional, and two $(n-1)$-dimensional ones. So if $n\ge8$ is the smallest value with a counterexample, then the rep must remain irreducible when restricted to any of the $n$ conjugate 'point stabilizer' subgroups isomorphic to $S_{n-1}$. The restriction cannot be a sum of 1-dimensional reps, because then the copies of $A_{n-1}$ (and hence $A_n$) would act trivially. The remaining problem would be to show that neither of the $n-2$ reps of $S_{n-1}$ can be a restriction of a rep of $S_n$. –  Jyrki Lahtonen Oct 3 '11 at 20:36
The result is true as stated for complex representations, but it is not true in general in other characteristics. For example, $S_n$ has a faithful irreducible representation of degree at most $n-2$ in characteristic $p$ whenever $p$ is a prime divisor of $n$ and $n >4.$ Take the obvious permutation module. Then $n$-long column vectors with zero sum form a submodule, but this submodule contains the span of the all-1 vector, which is invariant. I realise that characteristic 0 was the intent of the question, but it illustrates that the question is subtle. –  Geoff Robinson Dec 20 '11 at 16:43

1 Answer 1

Following Jyricki's excellent suggestion, I will show that, for $n \neq 4$, the $n-2$ dimensional representations of $S_{n-1}$ do not extend to representations of $S_n$. Let $V$ be the vector space of $(n-1)$-tuples of real numbers adding up to $0$, with $S_{n-1}$ acting by permutation. I will show that this does not extend to an action of $S_n$.

Suppose for the sake of contradiction that there is an action of $S_n$ on $V$ extending the action of $S_{n-1}$. Since this is an action of a finite group in characteristic zero, it preserves a symmetric bilinear form. There is only one (up to scaling) $S_{n-1}$-invariant symmetric bilinear form on $V$ -- namely, the one induced from the standard inner product on $\mathbb{R}^{n-1}$. So $S_n$ must preserve this inner product.

For $1 \leq i, j < n$, the transposition $(i j)$ acts on $V$ by orthogonal reflection in the vector $e_i - e_j$. Since $(i n)$ and $(i j)$ are conjugate in $S_n$, we know that $(i n)$ acts by orthogonal reflection in some vector; call it $v_i$.

For $1 \leq j,k < n$, with $i \neq j$, $k$, the reflections $(i n)$ and $(j k)$ commute. This means that $e_j -e_k$ and $v_i$ must be orthogonal. So $v_i$ must be of the form $$v_i = a \cdot \left( \sum_{j \neq i} e_j - (n-2) e_i \right)$$ for some scalar $a$.

Now recall that ${\Large (} (ij) (in) {\Large )}^3 = \mathrm{Id}$. So the angle between $v_i$ and $e_i - e_j$ must be $\pi/3$ or $2 \pi /3$. We compute $$|e_i - e_j| = \sqrt{2}$$ $$|v_i| = a \sqrt{(n-2)+(n-2)^2 } = a \sqrt{(n-1)(n-2)}$$ $$\langle e_i - e_j, v_i \rangle = a \left( -(n-2) - 1 \right) = - a (n-1).$$ So the angle between $v_i$ and $e_i -e _j$ is $$\cos^{-1} \left( \frac{-(n-1)}{\sqrt{2(n-1)(n-2)}} \right).$$

When $n=4$, this is $\cos^{-1} (-\sqrt{3}/2) = 2 \pi /3$. And, indeed, when $n=4$, the action does extend! But for $n>4$, $\frac{(n-1)}{\sqrt{2(n-1)(n-2)}} \neq \pm \sqrt{3}/2$, so the action does not extend.

Now, a quick sketch of how to finish the problem from here. We prove by induction the statement

For $n \geq 5$, the only representations of $S_n$ of dimension $<n$ are direct sums of (a) the trivial rep (b) the sign rep (c) the $n-1$ dimensional rep on $n$-tuples of numbers summing to $0$ and (d) the tensor product of (b) and (c).

The base case is left to you; starting by considering the eigenvalues of the $5$-cycle is a good idea.

Let $W$ be a rep of $S_n$ of dimension $<n$. Consider the restriction of $W$ to $S_{n-1}$. If $\dim W < n-2$, then induction shows that it is a direct sum of (a)'s and (b)'s, and I leave it as an exercise to show that $W$ is the same direct sum as a representation of $S_n$.

If $\dim W = n-2$ and $W$ is not made up of (a)'s and (b)'s, then $W$ is either type (c) or type (d). The above result gives a contradiction in the first case, and tensoring with the sign rep and then applying the above result gives a contradiction in the second case.

Finally, we must deal with the possibilities when $\dim V = n-1$. Details are left to you, but I think modifying the above argument will do this case as well.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.