Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Let $A = \{x \sin x : x \in \mathbb{Z}\} \subset \mathbb{R}$. Is $A$ a ring under the usual addition and multiplication operations of $\mathbb{R}$? It looks like it's not, but I can't find something concrete to justify this.

share|cite|improve this question
Under what operations ? The usual ones in $\;\Bbb R\;$ ? – DonAntonio Feb 25 '14 at 16:36
Is this even closed under negation? After all, $(-x)\sin(-x) = x\sin x$ because $\sin x = -\sin (-x)$... – fgp Feb 25 '14 at 16:49
It's not immediately clear why there isn't some $y\in\mathbb{Z}$ such that $y\sin{y}=-x\sin{x}$ though (I agree that this is unlikely). – Matthew Pressland Feb 25 '14 at 16:55
To take things even further (and actually possibly point to a proof): is there even one non-trivial identity among some finite number of members of $A$? – Steven Stadnicki Feb 25 '14 at 17:16
Another identity is that $f(1 \sin 1, 2 \sin 2) = 0$ where $$f(x,y) = y^2 - 8 x^2 (1-x^2) (1-2x^2)^2$$ – Hurkyl Feb 25 '14 at 17:32
up vote 13 down vote accepted

Suppose $A$ were a ring; then in particular, we have $2\sin 1=n\sin n$ for some $n$. Now, use the duplication formulas for $\sin$ to write $\sin n$ as $(\sin 1)\cdot P_n(\cos 1)$, where $P_n(x)$ is a polynomial of degree $n$ (this can be shown straightforwardly via induction; these polynomials are known as the Chebyshev polynomials of the second kind). This yields an identity of the form $nP_n(\cos 1)-2=0$, contradicting the fact that $\cos 1$ is transcendental. In fact, this shows that no non-trivial linear relation can hold among any finite number of members of $A$.

share|cite|improve this answer
Could you at least hint at a justification of the last sentence? – Manny Reyes Feb 25 '14 at 17:28
@MannyReyes I should correct that to 'additive identity', actually (I was thinking of $A$ as a group, not a ring). The proof in that case is almost identical: use the $\sin n$ identity to write each of the terms in the form $(\sin 1)\cdot P_n(\cos 1)$, sum, and derive a contradiction. – Steven Stadnicki Feb 25 '14 at 17:31
Thanks, the "additive identity" helps a lot. So it seems that you're actually proving that $\{\sin(n) \mid n \in \mathbb{N}\}$ is a $\mathbb{Z}$-linearly independent subset of $\mathbb{R}$. Very nice! – Manny Reyes Feb 25 '14 at 17:35
(Note that similarly to a now-deleted answer from @MarcinŁoś, this uses the Lindemann-Weirstraß theorem to derive its conclusion - in my case, it's implicit in the assertion that $\cos 1$ is transcendental.) – Steven Stadnicki Feb 25 '14 at 20:39

There is no 1 (multiplicative identity) so it is not a ring. x sin(x) is either 0 (when x=0) or is a transcendental number due to Lindemann–Weierstrass theorem when x <> 0

share|cite|improve this answer
Depends on your definition of a ring. Rings are not usually required to have an identity though. – the_fox Mar 5 '14 at 17:31
True that is unclear from the question if they mean ring with identity or not. The other answer also assumes there is a 1 in the ring when it say there is an n such that 2 sin 1 = n sin n. Because the 2 here is an element 2 in the ring to multiply 1 sin 1 by. Hence it assumes there is a 1 in the ring to make the element 2 from. – Michael Smith Mar 5 '14 at 21:09
Now I am curious if you assume that there is not a 1 in the ring if you can still prove the statement :-) – Michael Smith Mar 5 '14 at 21:15
I think that Steven's answer tackles closure of addition, i.e. whether $1\sin 1 + 1 \sin 1 = 2\sin 1$ is an element of this set or not. – the_fox Mar 6 '14 at 1:36
Aha I had missed that point. Thanks for explaining! So given we are using the 1 from R here in regular way it seems like we must be assuming the ring has identity. – Michael Smith Mar 6 '14 at 10:48

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.