Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Where is the flaw in my reasoning?

$$y''=y \iff y'=\frac{y^2}{2} \iff y=\frac{y^3}{6}$$

share|improve this question
    
Remember that you are dealing with $$\frac{d^2y(x)}{dx^2} = y(x) $$ –  Mhenni Benghorbal Feb 2 at 3:18
    
Even if your approach were right (see answers) you would be missing constants of integration. Claude's solution shows how you get two constants to be determined from boundary conditions. –  Mark Bennet Feb 2 at 6:33
add comment

2 Answers

up vote 9 down vote accepted

when you write $y''$ you mean differentiating with respect to some variable $x$.

However $\int y dy = y^2/2$

So when you go from $y''$ to $y'$ you are integrating with respect to $x$

So when you go from $y$ to $y^2/2$ you are integrating with respect to $y$

That is the flaw in your logic.

If you write out $$ \frac{d y^2}{d x^2} = y $$ then $$ \frac{d y}{d x} = \int y ~dx $$

For this reason alone, I am not a big fan of $y'$, $y''$ etc.

share|improve this answer
3  
Leibniz notation is far from perfect. Why not just write $y'(x)$ instead? –  nsanger Feb 2 at 3:50
    
The problem is, it does not say what the independent variable is. For example, how will you interpret $y'(0)=2$? While I agree that Leibniz's notation also has ambiguities it at least shows what the independent varible is –  user44197 Feb 2 at 3:56
    
If you're working with a differential equation, then you'll be writing $y'(x)$ which makes it clear what the independent variable is. If you're working with expressions like $y'(3)$, then what the independent variable is should have been specified, but even if it hasn't it shouldn't matter since it's just a constant. –  nsanger Feb 2 at 4:13
    
no, only $\dot{y}$ is correct, both $\frac{dy}{dx}$ and $y'$ are wrong ;) –  James S. Cook Feb 2 at 4:56
    
I still teach using a black board and I am not known to clean the black board all that well, so I don't like either $\dot{y}$ or $y'$ ;) –  user44197 Feb 2 at 5:26
add comment

As said in previous answers, the problem is much clearer if you rewrite $$y''=y$$ as $$ \frac{d^2 y}{d x^2} = y$$ This really shows the dependencies between $y$ and $x$.

So, you face a second order differential equation the characteristic equation being $r^2=1$ which has two roots $r=1$ and $r=-1$; so its general solution write $$y=c_1 e^x+c_2 e^{-x}$$

share|improve this answer
    
why not $\frac{d^2 y}{d x^2} = y$? –  dwarandae Feb 2 at 6:43
    
@dwarandae. Thanks for reporting the typo. Fixed now. –  Claude Leibovici Feb 2 at 7:15
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.