Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Say, we have three Banach spaces $X, Y, Z$ and $g:X \to Y, \ \ f:Y \to Z$ are twice (Fréchet) differenciable. The question is: what is $(f \circ g)''$?

Since $(f \circ g)'':X \to \mathcal{L}^2(X,Z)$, I am interested in the most explicit form: $(f \circ g)''(a)[k, h]$ which would describe the entire action taking place.

Let's pick some $a \in X$ and get started:

\begin{align} \\ (f \circ g)''(a)[k, h] &= D_{k}D_{h}(f \circ g)(a) \\ &= D_{k} \bigg( D_{h}(f \circ g)(a) \bigg) \\ &= D_{k} \bigg( (f \circ g)'(a)[h] \bigg) \\ &= \bigg( D_{k} (f \circ g)'(a)\bigg) [h] \ \ \ \ \ \text{(by linearity)} \\ &= \bigg( D_{k} f'(g(a)) \circ g'(a)\bigg) [h] \ \ \ \ \ \text{(chain rule)} \\ &= \bigg( \frac{d}{dt} f'(g(a+tk)) \circ g'(a+tk)|_{t=0}\bigg) [h] \end{align}

I’m really confused what to do next. It looks like we’d need to apply some sort of the product rule (but there is no product here: only compositions). And whatever I do next, I immediately lose track of how it all fits with $k$ and $h$.

Any explanations (the more detailed the better) are hugely appreciated.

share|cite|improve this question

First of all consider that by the chain rule: $(g\circ f)''(z)=(g'(f(z))\circ f'(z))'$

Now, $g'(f(z))$ and $f'(z)$ are continuous linear functions because $f$ and $g$ are twice Frechet differentiable. With this, consider the function $c(a,b)=a\circ b$ for continuous linear functions $a$ and $b$. Then $c$ is a bilinear continuous functions.

So, we have that:

$$(g'(f(z))\circ f'(z))'=(c(g'(f(z)), f'(z)))'=c'(g'(f(z)), f'(z))\circ((g'\circ f(z))',f''(z))$$

And using the fact that $c$ is bilinear continuous, one has that

$$c'(g'(f(z)), f'(z))\circ((g'\circ f(z))',f''(z))=c(g'\circ f(z),f''(z))+c(g''\circ f(z)\circ f'(z),f'(z))=g'(f(z))\circ f''(z)+g''(f(z))\circ f'(z)\circ f'(z)=g''(f(z))\circ (f'(z),f'(z))+g'(f(z))\circ f''(z)$$

So $(g\circ f)''(z)=g''(f(z))\circ (f'(z),f'(z))+g'(f(z))\circ f''(z)$.

share|cite|improve this answer

The composition sign in the line marked (chain rule) should be a product sign. By "normal" differentiation the final answer would be $f''(g(a))g'(a)+f'(g(a)g''(a)$.

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.