Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Let $M$, $L$, $N$ be $A$-modules and $M=N\oplus L$. If $M$ and $N$ are free, is $L$ necessarily free?

share|cite|improve this question
up vote 12 down vote accepted

Let $M$ be a module over a commutative ring. Recall three properties:

$M$ is projective if it is a direct summand of a free module.
$M$ is weakly stably free if there exists a free module $F$ such that $M \oplus F$ is free.
$M$ is stably free if there exists a finitely generated free module $F$ such that $M \oplus F$ is free.

Then free implies stably free implies weakly stably free implies projective.

But actually projective implies weakly stably free: this is called the Eilenberg swindle. Thus if you don't require $F$ to be finitely generated, then any nonfree projective module gives a negative answer to this question. There are "cheap" examples of this: e.g. let $R_1$ and $R_2$ be any two nonzero rings, let $R = R_1 \times R_2$, and consider $R_1$ as an $R$-module: it is projective but not free.

What about stably free modules which are not free? Here counterexamples lie much deeper. Plop has described what is in fact the most standard counterexample, which reduces the problem to a nontrivial fact in differential topology. A somewhat more comprehensive discussion of this class of examples can be found in $\S 6.4.3$ of my commutative algebra notes. Also, at the end of $\S 3.5$ I give the Eilenberg Swindle as an exercise, with a big hint.

Added: To the best of my recollection, the terminology "weakly stably free" is not standard but something that I made up while writing up my notes. But the point of course is that after this little discussion involving the Eilenberg Swindle, one sees that such terminology is not needed.

share|cite|improve this answer
Is there an easy example of a projective module that is not stably free? – Leon Feb 12 '12 at 17:50
@Leon: a finitely generated projective $R$-module is stably free iff its class in the $K$-group $K_0(R)$ is trivial. So you want examples of rings $R$ with nontrivial $K_0(R)$. Probably the simplest is a Dedekind domain which is not a PID, in which case a nonprincipal ideal gives an example. – Pete L. Clark Feb 12 '12 at 19:28
@Leon: or, if you like topology, by Swan's theorem the Mobius band viewed as a projective module over the ring of continuous functions on the circle is not stably free. – Pete L. Clark Feb 13 '12 at 22:59

No, for example the tangent vector bundle of the sphere $S^2$ is non-trivial, whereas the normal vector bundle is. More concretely, $A=\mathbb{R}[x,y,z]/(x^2+y^2+z^2-1)$, $L=\{(P_1,P_2,P_3)\ |\ xP_1+yP_2+zP_3=0\}$, $N=A \cdot (x,y,z)$, $M=A^3$.

share|cite|improve this answer
May I ask where you learned this material? Could you elaborate on this a bit please. Is $A$, $L$, or $N$ the tangent vector bundle of $S^2$? How did you construct this? Can this be done for any (embedded) smooth manifold? For any variety in $\mathbb{R}^n$? I know there exists a book "Smooth Manifolds and Observables" by Jet Nestruev, which deals with this stuff, but I did not find the things I'm asking you there (I just glanced through). Where should I look? – Leon Feb 11 '12 at 7:31
@Leon: I added some details in the recent duplicate… – Hanno Nov 1 '14 at 18:20

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.