Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Let $X\to S$ be a scheme.

Definition: A relative effective Cartier divisor on $X/S$ is a closed subscheme $D\subset X$ such that the ideal sheaf $I$ of $D$ is invertible and $D\to S$ is flat.

Let now $T\to S$ be another scheme over $S$ and denote by $X_T$ the fibered product $X\times_S T$. I read on a paper the following:

Claim: Let $D$ be a relative effective Cartier divisor on $X_T/T$ and $p:T'\to T$ be an arbitrary $S$-map of schemes. Then the pullback $p^*_{X_T}(I)$ is the ideal sheaf of the $T'$-flat closed subscheme $D_{T'}\subset X_{T'}$. Hence $D_{T'}$ is a relative effective Cartier divisor on $X_{T'}/T'$.

Can you please help me proving the claim? In particular, the author says:

Since $D$ is $T$-flat, $p^*_{X_T} (I)$ is equal to the ideal of $D_{T'}$

And I don't understand why.

share|cite|improve this question
This is exactly what flatness means, perhaps you should write down the pullbacks and ideal sheaves in the affine case to see this. – Martin Brandenburg Nov 23 '13 at 22:36
@MartinBrandenburg: Dear Martin, I posted an attempt to prove the claim, but I still have doubts. Could you please help me clarifying? Thanks a lot, your help is precious as diamonds! – Abramo Nov 25 '13 at 9:25

Ok I think I really got it now! A nice way to prove the above claim is to use a basic result about purity:

The functor $\square\otimes_A B$ is exact if and only if every short exact sequence of $A$-modules ending with $B$ is pure

Recall that a short exact sequence of $A$-modules is pure if it stays exact when tensored with any $A$-module. $\newcommand{\Spec}{\operatorname{Spec}}$ $\newcommand{\SES}[3]{0\to #1 \to #2 \to #3 \to 0}$

Let's work affine locally, with $$ T=\Spec(R), \quad T'=\Spec(R'), \quad X_T=\Spec(S), \quad X_{T'}=\Spec(S') $$ and let $I\subset X_T$ be the ideal of $D$ and $I'$ the ideal of $D'=p^*{D}$.

Flatness of the map $D\to T$ is equivalent to the functor $\square\otimes_R S/I$ being exact. By the above result this implies that every short exact sequence of $R$-modules ending with $S/I$ is pure. In particular the sequence of $D$ $$ \SES{I}{S}{S/I} $$ is pure. Hence tensoring with any $R$-module leaves it exact and in particular $$ \SES{I\otimes_R R'}{S\otimes_R R'}{S/I\otimes_R R'} $$ is exact. Since the above sequence can be rewritten as $$ \SES{p^*I}{S'}{S'/I'} $$ we deduce that $p^*I = I'$, as desired.

share|cite|improve this answer
$\pi$ and its restriction toare flat $D'$ aren't necessarily going to be flat unless $T'\to T$ is. The point is that $\mathcal{O}_D$ is $T$-flat. Reduce to the affine case $T = \mathop{\text{Spec}}R$, $T' = \mathop{\text{Spec}} R'$, and $X = \mathop{\text{Spec}}S$, where exactness of $0\to I\to S\to S/I\to 0$ and flatness of $S/I\to R$ imply exactness of $0\to I\otimes_R R'\to S\otimes_R R'\to (S/I)\otimes_R R'\to 0$. – Jan Ladislav Dussek Nov 27 '13 at 1:14
Or look at EGA IV${}_2$ (2.1.8)(i) (which is the same argument, except in French) – Jan Ladislav Dussek Nov 27 '13 at 1:41

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.