Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

The Task: During a technical control lights and brakes was controlled on randomly selected cars. 18% had errors with the lights and 12% with the brakes. 74% had both lights and brakes in order. What is the probability that:
a) The lights were in order?
b) The brakes were in order?
c) No brakes and no lights?
d) Lights, but no brakes.

My answers(d is the problem):
a) 82%
b) 88%
c) 18+12-26=4%
d) What I have scribbled so far:
p(A) = Lights = 0.88, p(B) = brakes = 0.88 $P(A \cap B) = 0.74$
$P(A \cup B) = 0.88+0.82 - 0.74 = 0.96$ At least one of the two is functioning.
The complement of that last would be both is not working; 4%.
26% that both or at least one is not working.

From there I don't see what I'm suppose to do. The book says the answer is 8% on d). I'll check back here in the morning. Good night.

share|cite|improve this question
isn't the answer just is 82% x 12%? – Victor Jul 19 '11 at 23:02
@Alg: Saying that you will "check back in the morning" gives me the sense that you do not care about how to solve the problem. You only care about the answer to the problem. I find this attitude to be quite rude. Would you ever meet with a tutor, hand him or her your assignment, and then say: "I'm going to grab some lunch. I'll check back in with you in an hour."? – JavaMan Jul 19 '11 at 23:02
I agree with you. I just didn't want anyone to expect me to answer back right away, and I need to sleep. – Algific Jul 20 '11 at 12:11
up vote 4 down vote accepted

Please draw a Venn Diagram. Then everything will become clear.

I don't know how to draw a picture on this site, so will use $1000$ words instead.

Draw a rectangle. The rectangle (including the points inside) symbolically represents all cars, meaning $100\%$.

Draw two intersecting ovals inside the rectangle. The left oval is all no light cars, the right oval is all no brake cars. The region of intersection of the two ovals is then the no light no brake cars. Maybe label the left oval NL, the right oval NB.

[Or else the two ovals could represent good light, good brake. Doesn't really matter too much. But I will stick to my first choice, so forget this paragraph.]

Region NL has (symbolically) size $18$ (will forget about $\%$ stuff temporarily). Region NB has size $12$. But you saw that altogether they cover a region of size $26$ only, $4$ down from the sum $18+12$. So the intersection of the two ovals must represent size $4$. Region NL and NB has therefore size $4$, our probability is $4\%$.

Finally, we look at part (d), light and no brake. That's the region in NB but not in (NL and NB). Make sure you are clear on what region this is.

Its size is $12-4$. This is because NB has size $12$, but the common region has size $4$. Thus the correct answer is $8\%$.

All these calculations can be expressed using more formal language that involves $\cup$, $\cap$, and complement. But in my opinion the picture comes first, to supply the intuition. Once you know what's really happening, expressing this knowledge in set-theoretic language is fairly mechanical.

share|cite|improve this answer
Thank you very much, I tried to cut corners and not draw up stuff but it really is easier to just draw it up. – Algific Jul 20 '11 at 12:20

Hint: 82%-74%=8% good luck,you just try with (no error with the light- 74%)!

share|cite|improve this answer

If you know that 74% have both lights and brakes working and 82% have lights working, then 82%-74%=8% have lights but no brakes. Similarly 88%-74%=14% have brakes but no lights. That means 100%-74%-8%-14%=4% have no lights and no brakes.

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.